The Imperative of Digital Maturity in the National Health Service: A Comprehensive Analysis of Adoption and Integration of Medical Technologies

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

Abstract

Digital maturity within the National Health Service (NHS) stands as a foundational pillar determining its capacity to effectively implement and integrate innovative medical technologies. This comprehensive research report delves into the intricate landscape of digital maturity across NHS trusts, meticulously charting the various developmental stages, identifying a multifaceted array of enablers and persistent barriers to digital transformation, and critically analysing the profound influence these disparities exert on the successful adoption and integration of cutting-edge medical technologies. Furthermore, this report extensively explores strategic imperatives designed to fortify digital infrastructure, enhance data interoperability, and elevate staff digital literacy across the entire NHS ecosystem, thereby fostering a more resilient, efficient, and patient-centric healthcare service.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

1. Introduction

The integration of digital technologies into modern healthcare systems has transitioned from an aspirational goal to an undeniable imperative, recognised globally as pivotal for enhancing service delivery, improving patient outcomes, and ensuring operational resilience and efficiency. In the highly complex and extensive context of the NHS, digital maturity signifies an organisation’s holistic ability to not only adapt to but also strategically integrate technological advancements into its core clinical and administrative operations. This encompasses a broad spectrum of capabilities, including the robust development of a scalable and secure digital infrastructure, the deliberate cultivation of a digitally literate and adaptable workforce, and the meticulous establishment of interoperable systems that facilitate seamless, secure, and timely information exchange across organisational boundaries.

The NHS, one of the world’s largest healthcare providers, serves a population of over 67 million people, delivering care across a diverse network of acute hospitals, community services, mental health trusts, and primary care settings (NHS England, 2023a). The inherent scale and complexity of this system mean that variations in digital readiness are not merely inconvenient but pose significant systemic challenges. These varying levels of digital maturity among NHS trusts present substantial hurdles in the effective implementation of a wide array of innovations, from foundational electronic patient record (EPR) systems to advanced artificial intelligence (AI) diagnostics, and specific initiatives such as the Innovator Passport – a system meticulously designed to streamline the adoption of new medical technologies by providing a clear pathway for evaluation and deployment (NHS England, 2023b).

Understanding these profound disparities is not just an academic exercise but an essential prerequisite for formulating targeted, equitable, and efficient strategies that promote a comprehensive digital transformation across the entire NHS. Such understanding allows for tailored interventions that address specific needs, rather than a one-size-fits-all approach that risks exacerbating existing inequalities and hindering the widespread benefit of digital innovation. The ultimate goal is to evolve into a ‘learning health system’ where data, technology, and human expertise converge to continuously improve care, foster research, and enhance the patient and staff experience.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

2. Digital Maturity in the NHS: Current Landscape

Digital maturity within the NHS is far from uniform; it exhibits significant variability across different trusts, reflecting a complex interplay of historical factors, current investment, and strategic priorities. This variability is profoundly influenced by a confluence of factors including organisational culture, the unwavering commitment of leadership, the availability and allocation of financial resources, and the quality and modernity of existing technological infrastructure.

To provide a structured approach to evaluation, NHS England developed the Digital Maturity Assessment Framework. This framework is a comprehensive tool designed to help trusts understand their current state of digital development and identify areas for improvement. It typically focuses on several key domains:

• Leadership and Governance: Assessing the clarity of digital vision, strategic alignment, and the presence of dedicated digital leadership roles (e.g., Chief Information Officer, Chief Clinical Information Officer).
• Workforce Capability: Evaluating staff digital literacy, training programmes, and the extent to which digital skills are embedded across the organisation.
• Infrastructure and Architecture: Examining the modernity, scalability, and security of IT systems, networks, and hardware.
• Data Utilisation and Analytics: Assessing the capability to collect, store, analyse, and leverage data for clinical decision-making, operational efficiency, and population health management.
• Clinical Engagement and Transformation: Measuring the active involvement of clinicians in digital initiatives and the impact of technology on clinical workflows and patient care pathways.
• Patient Empowerment and Digital Access: Evaluating the provision of digital tools for patients (e.g., online booking, patient portals, remote monitoring) and efforts to address digital inclusion.
• Cyber Security and Information Governance: Assessing the robustness of systems and processes to protect patient data and ensure compliance with regulations (NHS England, 2023c).

Despite the existence of such robust frameworks and national directives, many trusts continue to grapple with persistent challenges that impede their digital progression. Reports from organisations like NHS Providers and The King’s Fund consistently highlight a fragmented landscape. For instance, a 2024 survey by NHS Providers revealed that a substantial majority of trust leaders – 73% – identified funding and financial constraints as the primary obstacle to digital transformation (NHS Providers, 2024a). Beyond finances, operational pressures, legacy IT systems, and issues with workforce digital literacy are consistently cited as major impediments (NHS Providers, 2024b; Health Foundation, 2024a).

Initiatives such as the Global Digital Exemplar (GDE) programme, launched in 2016, aimed to establish a network of digitally advanced trusts to serve as exemplars and share best practices across the NHS (Wikipedia, 2022). While GDEs successfully demonstrated what ‘good’ looks like and accelerated digital maturity in some areas, the programme also underscored the significant investment and sustained effort required to achieve advanced digital status, revealing the depth of the digital divide between leading trusts and those lagging behind. This disparity often translates into a ‘postcode lottery’ for patients, where access to digitally enabled care and innovative treatments varies depending on where they receive care. The current landscape is therefore characterised by pockets of excellence alongside significant areas requiring substantial uplift, highlighting the need for a comprehensive, system-wide approach to digital transformation rather than isolated efforts.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

3. Stages of Digital Development

Digital development within the NHS can be conceptualised as a dynamic continuum, illustrating the varying levels of sophistication and integration of technology across trusts. While specific labels may vary, a generally accepted model depicts a progression through distinct stages of maturity, each characterised by specific technological capabilities, operational processes, and organisational culture. This progression is not always linear and trusts may exhibit strengths in some areas while lagging in others.

3.1. Initial Stage: Foundational and Fragmented

At the initial stage, trusts typically possess limited digital capabilities, with minimal, often uncoordinated, integration of technology into clinical and administrative processes. Dependence on paper-based records remains high, leading to inherent inefficiencies, data fragmentation, and potential risks to patient safety due to incomplete or inaccessible information. Basic digital tools, such as email and standalone departmental systems, may exist, but they often operate in silos with little to no interoperability. There is an absence of a clear, overarching strategic vision for digital transformation, and investment in IT is often reactive rather than proactive. Staff engagement with technology may be low, and digital literacy is often rudimentary. Challenges include a lack of basic network infrastructure, outdated hardware, and a prevailing culture of resistance to change, where digital solutions are perceived as an ‘add-on’ rather than an integral part of service delivery.

3.2. Developing Stage: Emerging Digitalisation and Siloed Systems

Trusts at the developing stage begin to make significant strides in implementing core digital solutions, most notably electronic patient record (EPR) systems. These systems aim to centralise patient information, moving away from fragmented paper charts. However, a common characteristic of this stage is that these systems, even if comprehensive within a single department or specialty, frequently operate in silos, lacking seamless interoperability with other systems within the same trust or with external healthcare providers. This often results in data duplication, manual re-entry of information, and the persistence of ‘paperarounds’ where digital systems don’t fully support clinical workflows. There is an emerging recognition of the critical need for a cohesive digital strategy, but its execution can be hampered by technical complexities, budget limitations, and a lack of standardised processes. Workforce training begins, but consistent adoption remains a challenge, and staff may perceive new systems as adding to their workload rather than alleviating it. Data analytics capabilities are nascent, often limited to basic reporting rather than insightful, predictive analysis.

3.3. Established Stage: Integration and Data-Driven Foundations

At the established stage, trusts have successfully integrated a significant proportion of their digital technologies into core operations. Key systems, including EPRs, picture archiving and communication systems (PACS), and order communications systems, are largely interoperable, facilitating substantial data exchange across departments and often with primary care. This level of integration enables more comprehensive, real-time patient records, supporting improved clinical decision-making and enhanced care coordination. Data-driven decision-making becomes more prevalent, with trusts beginning to leverage analytics for operational efficiency, quality improvement, and clinical audits. There is a clear alignment between digital initiatives and broader organisational objectives, supported by dedicated digital leadership and governance structures. A culture of digital adoption is taking root, with staff generally comfortable with and advocating for the use of digital tools. Patient-facing digital services, such as online appointment booking and basic patient portals, are often introduced, beginning to empower patients in their own care journey. The focus shifts from merely implementing technology to optimising its use and demonstrating tangible benefits.

3.4. Advanced Stage: Innovation, Analytics, and Transformative Care

Trusts reaching the advanced stage exhibit a high level of digital maturity, characterised by sophisticated data analytics capabilities, widespread and embedded use of digital tools across all levels of the organisation, and a deeply ingrained culture that embraces continuous digital innovation. Here, advanced technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI) for diagnostics, machine learning for predictive analytics, remote patient monitoring, and digital therapeutics are not merely experimental but are actively integrated into clinical pathways. Interoperability extends beyond the trust boundary, connecting seamlessly with social care, mental health services, and community care, forming truly integrated care systems. Patient empowerment is paramount, with comprehensive patient portals offering full access to records, proactive health management tools, and virtual consultation options. The workforce is highly digitally literate and engaged, viewing technology as an enabler for better, safer, and more efficient care. These trusts actively participate in research and development, contributing to the broader digital health ecosystem, and are often seen as leaders in defining the future of healthcare delivery (NHS England, 2023d). The focus is on harnessing data to create a ‘learning health system’ that constantly optimises care based on real-world evidence.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

4. Enablers of Digital Transformation

Achieving digital maturity within the NHS is a complex endeavour facilitated by several critical enablers that must be strategically cultivated and sustained. These enablers act as catalysts, accelerating the journey from fragmented systems to integrated, innovative healthcare delivery.

4.1. Leadership Commitment and Visionary Strategy

Strong, visible leadership is arguably the most critical enabler for driving digital initiatives. This extends beyond merely allocating resources to establishing a clear, compelling digital vision that resonates throughout the organisation. Leaders, particularly those at executive and board levels (e.g., Chief Executive, Medical Director, Chief Nurse, Chief Information Officer, Chief Clinical Information Officer), must champion digital transformation, articulate its strategic importance, and foster a culture of innovation and adaptability (Netcall & Davies, 2022). This involves setting ambitious but realistic objectives, communicating the ‘why’ behind the change, and demonstrating unwavering commitment through consistent messaging and resource allocation. Effective digital leadership also entails robust governance structures, ensuring accountability, managing risks, and enabling agile decision-making. Without a cohesive leadership vision, digital projects risk becoming isolated, opportunistic endeavours rather than integrated components of a long-term strategic plan.

4.2. Sustainable Financial Investment

Adequate and sustainable funding is fundamental for developing, maintaining, and continually upgrading digital infrastructure, training staff, and implementing new technologies. Digital transformation is not a one-off expenditure but a continuous investment requiring capital for hardware and software, and revenue for licensing, maintenance, and ongoing support. The NHS has historically struggled with fragmented and often insufficient IT budgets, frequently diverting funds from digital projects to address immediate operational pressures (NHS Providers, 2024a). Sustainable and balanced funding models, potentially ring-fenced for digital initiatives, are necessary to support long-term digital strategies and prevent short-term savings from compromising future capabilities. This also requires a sophisticated understanding of the return on investment (ROI) from digital programmes, which often manifests in long-term efficiency gains, improved patient outcomes, and enhanced safety rather than immediate cost reductions.

4.3. Workforce Capability and Digital Literacy

A digitally literate and engaged workforce is paramount to the successful adoption and effective utilisation of digital tools. This extends beyond basic computer skills to encompass a deeper understanding of how technology can enhance clinical practice, administrative efficiency, and patient care. Continuous professional development and comprehensive training programmes are vital to enhance digital skills among all NHS staff, from frontline clinicians to administrative personnel. These programmes must be tailored to different roles and levels of existing proficiency, incorporating practical, hands-on experience and ongoing support. Furthermore, fostering a ‘digital-first’ mindset, where staff are encouraged to explore and champion digital solutions, is crucial. This also involves addressing digital inclusion within the workforce, ensuring that no staff member is left behind due to a lack of access or skills (NHS England, 2023e).

4.4. Effective Data Utilisation and Analytics

Beyond merely collecting data, the effective utilisation of data analytics is a powerful enabler. Trusts that leverage data effectively are better positioned to inform evidence-based decision-making, improve patient outcomes, and optimise operational efficiency. This requires robust data governance frameworks to ensure data quality, security, and privacy, alongside advanced analytics platforms capable of processing large, complex datasets. The ability to transform raw data into actionable insights can drive improvements in patient pathways, identify health inequalities, predict demand, and personalise care. This also involves embracing AI and machine learning capabilities to extract deeper insights and automate processes, moving towards a truly data-driven learning health system where continuous improvement is embedded.

4.5. Strategic Partnerships and Collaboration

Collaboration with technology vendors, academic institutions, other NHS trusts, and international healthcare systems can significantly accelerate digital transformation. Strategic partnerships can bring in external expertise, facilitate access to cutting-edge technologies, and provide opportunities for co-development and testing of innovative solutions. Learning from the successes and failures of others, both within and outside the NHS, can help trusts avoid common pitfalls and adopt proven best practices. Initiatives that promote shared learning and resource pooling, such as the GDE programme, demonstrate the power of collaborative networks in elevating digital maturity across the system.

4.6. Patient Engagement and Co-design

Involving patients and the public in the design, development, and implementation of digital health solutions is increasingly recognised as a vital enabler. Solutions co-designed with end-users are more likely to be user-friendly, meet genuine needs, and achieve higher adoption rates. Patient feedback can provide invaluable insights, ensuring that technology serves to empower patients in managing their health, accessing services, and interacting with healthcare providers. This approach not only improves the utility of digital tools but also fosters trust and enhances the overall patient experience, aligning digital transformation with the core mission of patient-centric care.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

5. Barriers to Digital Transformation

Despite the clear potential benefits and the presence of significant enablers, the NHS faces a formidable array of challenges that persistently impede digital transformation efforts. These barriers are often interconnected, creating a complex web of obstacles that require multi-faceted and sustained solutions.

5.1. Financial Constraints and Underinvestment

Limited budgets and pervasive financial pressures constitute a perennial and significant barrier to digital transformation within the NHS. A substantial portion of the NHS budget is allocated to operational costs, leaving insufficient capital for long-term strategic investments in digital infrastructure and innovation. A 2024 survey by NHS Providers starkly highlighted this, with 73% of trust leaders identifying funding as the main barrier (NHS Providers, 2024a). This underinvestment manifests in several ways: deferred upgrades of essential IT hardware and software, inability to recruit and retain highly skilled digital staff, and a reluctance to invest in new, potentially transformative technologies due to perceived high upfront costs. The capital funding for IT is often insufficient to address the scale of required improvements, forcing trusts to make difficult choices between urgent clinical priorities and crucial digital upgrades. The long-term savings and efficiency gains offered by digital solutions are often overshadowed by immediate financial pressures, creating a vicious cycle of reactive rather than proactive investment.

5.2. Operational Pressures and Competing Priorities

The relentless operational pressures faced by NHS trusts, including high workloads, staff shortages, and ever-present demands to meet targets and manage crises (e.g., winter pressures, elective backlogs), significantly hinder staff engagement with digital initiatives. Clinical teams often struggle with time constraints for training, system implementation, and adapting to new digital workflows. The ‘tyranny of the urgent’ frequently overrides the ‘importance of the strategic,’ meaning that long-term digital projects are deprioritised in favour of immediate patient care demands (Digital Health Technology News, 2022). This environment makes it challenging to dedicate the necessary time and resources to embedding new technologies, leading to suboptimal utilisation, staff burnout, and resistance to change. Staff may perceive new digital tools as an additional burden rather than a solution, particularly if their introduction is poorly managed or training is inadequate.

5.3. Legacy Systems and Technical Debt

Many NHS trusts continue to grapple with outdated IT infrastructure and systems, often referred to as ‘legacy systems,’ which pose a formidable barrier to the integration of new technologies. These systems, some decades old, are frequently fragmented, difficult to maintain, prone to failure, and lack the interoperability required for modern digital solutions (Netcall & Davies, 2022; Health Foundation, 2024b). Examples include disparate patient administration systems (PAS), paper-based records that are still prevalent in some areas, and bespoke departmental systems that cannot communicate with each other. The sheer scale and cost of replacing these legacy systems constitute significant ‘technical debt.’ Modernising requires not only substantial financial investment but also careful planning to avoid disruption to critical patient services during the transition. Furthermore, the reliance on outdated technology creates cybersecurity vulnerabilities and limits the ability to leverage advanced data analytics or cloud-based solutions.

5.4. Interoperability Issues and Data Silos

The persistent lack of standardised systems and protocols across the NHS is a critical impediment to seamless data exchange between different healthcare providers and even within individual trusts. This results in fragmented patient care, where crucial information may not follow the patient across different care settings (e.g., from an ambulance to A&E, or from acute care to community services). The absence of common data standards, the proliferation of proprietary vendor systems, and a historical lack of a ‘single source of truth’ for patient data contribute to extensive data silos. Initiatives like the Professional Record Standards Body (PRSB) and the development of national standards (e.g., FHIR – Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources) aim to address this, but their widespread adoption and implementation remain a significant challenge. The clinical and operational consequences of poor interoperability are profound, leading to delays in diagnosis and treatment, duplicated tests, increased administrative burden, and potential risks to patient safety.

5.5. Digital Literacy Gaps and Workforce Resistance

Insufficient digital skills among the vast and diverse NHS workforce significantly limit the effective use of digital tools. A significant proportion of NHS staff, particularly those with longer service or in certain demographic groups, report struggling to use electronic records effectively due to inadequate training and support (Health Foundation, 2024a). This ‘digital divide’ within the workforce impacts not only efficiency but also staff morale and patient safety. Beyond technical proficiency, cultural resistance to change, often stemming from a lack of understanding, fear of job displacement, or prior negative experiences with poorly implemented systems, can be a major barrier (Tech Monitor, 2022). Overcoming this requires more than just training; it necessitates comprehensive change management, clear communication of benefits, engagement with clinical champions, and a supportive environment where staff feel confident to learn and adapt.

5.6. Cybersecurity Concerns and Data Protection

The increasing reliance on digital systems brings heightened risks regarding cybersecurity and data protection. The NHS handles highly sensitive personal and health information, making it a prime target for cyberattacks. The WannaCry ransomware attack in 2017 vividly demonstrated the vulnerability of NHS systems and the potential for widespread disruption to patient care (NHS England, 2017). The constant threat of data breaches, ransomware, and other cyberattacks necessitates robust security measures, which can be costly and complex to implement and maintain. Concerns about patient data privacy and compliance with regulations like GDPR and the Caldicott Principles can also slow down data sharing initiatives and the adoption of new technologies, requiring careful balancing of innovation with stringent security and privacy protocols.

5.7. Complex Procurement Processes

The NHS’s complex and often protracted procurement processes can be a significant barrier to adopting agile and innovative technological solutions. The long lead times, bureaucratic requirements, and focus on lowest cost rather than best value or long-term interoperability can deter smaller, innovative tech companies and delay the implementation of much-needed solutions. This contrasts sharply with the rapid pace of technological development, often leaving the NHS playing catch-up. Reforming procurement to be more agile, outcome-focused, and supportive of innovation is a critical step towards accelerating digital transformation.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

6. Impact of Digital Maturity on Adoption of Medical Technologies

The level of digital maturity within an NHS trust directly and profoundly influences its capacity, speed, and success rate in adopting, integrating, and fully leveraging new medical technologies. This relationship is not merely correlational; digital maturity acts as a foundational prerequisite for deriving the full benefits from technological innovations across the healthcare continuum.

6.1. Challenges at Lower Maturity Levels

Trusts operating at lower levels of digital maturity face substantial challenges in implementing new medical technologies. These challenges are systemic and interconnected:

• Inadequate Infrastructure: A lack of modern, scalable, and secure IT infrastructure means that new technologies – whether advanced imaging systems, AI diagnostic tools, or sophisticated remote monitoring platforms – cannot be adequately supported. Insufficient network bandwidth, outdated servers, and incompatible operating systems create fundamental technical roadblocks. For instance, a trust with poor network connectivity would struggle to deploy cloud-based AI diagnostic software that relies on high-speed data transfer.
• Lack of Interoperability: New medical technologies, particularly those that generate or rely on patient data, require seamless integration with existing electronic patient records (EPRs) and other clinical systems. In a low-maturity environment characterised by data silos and proprietary systems, integrating an innovative device or software becomes an arduous, often impossible, task. This leads to fragmented data, duplicated entries, and a failure to create a holistic patient view, significantly diminishing the value proposition of the new technology. The Innovator Passport, designed to streamline adoption, would encounter severe bottlenecks here, as the ability to share data and integrate new solutions into existing workflows would be severely hampered.
• Limited Staff Training and Digital Literacy: Even if a new technology is procured, its effective utilisation hinges on the digital proficiency of the staff. In trusts with low digital literacy, staff may lack the foundational skills or confidence to operate new systems, leading to underutilisation, errors, and resistance. Comprehensive training programmes are essential, but time and resources for such training are often scarce in low-maturity settings. This means that a sophisticated robotic surgery system, for example, might be acquired but its full potential unrealised due to inadequate training or integration with surgical planning software.
• Suboptimal Utilisation and ROI: The cumulative effect of these challenges is that new medical technologies are often implemented partially, poorly, or not at all, leading to suboptimal utilisation. This directly impacts the expected return on investment (ROI), as the benefits in terms of improved patient care, efficiency, or cost savings are not fully realised. Funds invested in innovative technologies may therefore yield little tangible benefit, discouraging future innovation.

6.2. Advantages at Higher Maturity Levels

Conversely, trusts with high digital maturity are significantly better equipped to adopt and integrate new medical technologies, leading to a virtuous cycle of innovation and improvement:

• Seamless Integration and Rapid Deployment: Robust and interoperable digital infrastructure allows new technologies to be integrated quickly and efficiently into existing workflows. Standardised APIs (Application Programming Interfaces) and adherence to national data standards mean that data flows smoothly between systems, enabling a holistic patient record and supporting advanced analytics. This significantly shortens the time from procurement to clinical use, making initiatives like the Innovator Passport highly effective.
• Enhanced Data-Driven Decision Making: High-maturity trusts can leverage the data generated by new medical technologies – from real-time patient monitoring devices to AI-powered diagnostics – for comprehensive analysis. This data can inform clinical pathways, identify trends, predict patient deterioration, and personalise treatments, leading to truly evidence-based care. For instance, an AI-powered dermatology tool can be seamlessly integrated with an EPR, allowing data to be captured, analysed, and used to inform treatment plans and track patient progress across the patient journey.
• Improved Patient Care and Outcomes: The effective integration of new technologies, supported by a strong digital foundation, translates directly into improved patient care. This can manifest as faster diagnoses, more precise treatments, enhanced patient safety, and better patient experience through remote monitoring, virtual consultations, and personalised health management tools.
• Operational Efficiency and Innovation Culture: Digitally mature trusts experience greater operational efficiency, as manual processes are automated, and information is readily accessible. This frees up staff time for direct patient care and fosters a culture that actively seeks out and embraces continuous innovation. Staff in these environments are often digital champions, proactively identifying opportunities to use technology to solve clinical and operational challenges.
• Strategic Advantage and Research: Trusts with advanced digital capabilities are often at the forefront of medical research and development, collaborating with industry and academia to pilot and validate cutting-edge technologies. They become attractive partners for innovators and are better positioned to attract top talent, further accelerating their digital journey and contributing to the broader knowledge base of the NHS.

The Innovator Passport initiative perfectly illustrates this dichotomy. A trust with high digital maturity would have the infrastructure, interoperability, and skilled workforce to rapidly evaluate, pilot, and scale a new medical device or software solution endorsed by the passport. They could integrate its data into their EPR, train staff efficiently, and quickly demonstrate its impact on patient care or operational metrics. A low-maturity trust, however, would find the passport’s promise of streamlined adoption frustrated by its own internal limitations, leading to delays, difficulties, and potentially the non-adoption of valuable innovations, widening the innovation gap across the NHS.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

7. Strategies for Enhancing Digital Maturity

Advancing digital maturity across the diverse landscape of NHS trusts requires a multi-faceted and sustained strategic approach. These strategies must be integrated, address both technical and cultural aspects, and be supported by national policy and local leadership.

7.1. Develop and Implement a Clear, Ambitious Digital Strategy

Every NHS trust must establish a comprehensive, multi-year digital transformation plan that is closely aligned with both organisational goals and national NHS policy, such as the NHS Long Term Plan and the national digital health and care strategy (NHS England, 2023a). This plan should outline clear objectives, ambitious yet achievable timelines, and detailed resource requirements across capital and revenue budgets. It must articulate a compelling vision for how digital technology will fundamentally transform patient care and operational efficiency. Furthermore, it should embrace a ‘whole-system approach,’ considering the interconnectedness of primary, secondary, community, and mental health care, aiming for seamless care pathways across these sectors. The strategy must be regularly reviewed, updated, and communicated transparently to all stakeholders, fostering buy-in and shared understanding.

7.2. Invest in Modern, Scalable, and Secure Infrastructure

Significant and sustained investment in upgrading IT systems is paramount to support modern digital solutions, ensuring scalability, resilience, and interoperability. This includes:

• Cloud Computing Adoption: Migrating to secure, NHS-approved cloud platforms can offer greater flexibility, scalability, and cost-efficiency compared to maintaining on-premise legacy systems, while also enhancing data security and disaster recovery capabilities.
• Network Upgrades: Investing in high-speed, reliable network infrastructure (e.g., fibre optics, Wi-Fi 6) is crucial to support the increasing demand for data transfer from interconnected medical devices, telehealth, and data analytics.
• Cybersecurity Enhancement: Implementing state-of-the-art cybersecurity measures, including advanced threat detection, incident response planning, and regular security audits, is essential to protect patient data and maintain system integrity in an increasingly hostile digital environment.
• Modern Hardware and Devices: Ensuring staff have access to up-to-date, fit-for-purpose hardware (e.g., modern workstations, tablets for mobile working) can significantly improve user experience and reduce technical frustrations.
• Flexible Architecture: Moving towards open, modular system architectures that can integrate easily with a variety of applications and allow for future innovation without costly overhauls.

7.3. Foster a Proactive Digital Culture and Champion Change Management

Promoting a culture that enthusiastically embraces digital change is as important as the technology itself. This requires a robust change management strategy that addresses potential resistance, fear of the unknown, and skill gaps. Key elements include:

• Executive Buy-in and Visible Champions: Leaders must visibly champion digital initiatives and demonstrate their personal commitment to using new technologies.
• Engaging Staff Early: Involving frontline staff (clinical and administrative) in the design, selection, and implementation of digital tools ensures solutions are practical and user-friendly.
• Creating a Safe Environment for Learning: Encouraging experimentation, providing psychological safety for mistakes, and fostering a ‘no-blame’ culture when learning new systems.
• Celebrating Successes: Recognising and publicising successful digital implementations and the staff who drive them helps build momentum and enthusiasm.
• Establishing Digital Champions: Identifying and empowering ‘digital champions’ within departments who can provide peer support and advocate for digital adoption.

7.4. Enhance and Personalise Training Programs

Providing ongoing, tailored training is fundamental to developing digital skills across the diverse NHS workforce. Training programmes should be:

• Role-Specific: Customised to the specific needs and workflows of different staff groups (e.g., doctors, nurses, administrative staff).
• Continuous Professional Development (CPD): Digital skills training should be integrated into regular CPD frameworks, ensuring skills are continuously updated.
• Varied Methodologies: Utilising a mix of e-learning, hands-on workshops, simulation exercises, and peer-to-peer mentoring.
• Accessible and Flexible: Offering training at times and locations that minimise disruption to clinical duties, and providing remote learning options.
• Focused on ‘Why’ as well as ‘How’: Explaining the benefits of new technologies for patient care and efficiency, not just the technical steps.

7.5. Implement Robust Data Governance and Quality Frameworks

Establishing clear policies and procedures for data acquisition, storage, sharing, security, and ethical use is critical. This includes:

• Data Quality Assurance: Implementing processes to ensure data accuracy, completeness, and consistency at the point of entry.
• Information Governance Compliance: Adhering strictly to GDPR, Caldicott Principles, and other relevant regulations to protect patient privacy and maintain trust.
• Standardised Terminology: Adopting national and international clinical terminologies (e.g., SNOMED CT) and data standards (e.g., FHIR) to facilitate seamless data exchange and analysis.
• Data Stewardship: Clearly defining roles and responsibilities for data ownership, management, and use within the organisation.
• Ethical AI Guidelines: As AI becomes more prevalent, developing clear ethical guidelines for its use in clinical decision support and patient care.

7.6. Promote Interoperability and Standardisation Across Systems

Moving beyond siloed systems towards true interoperability is non-negotiable for a modern NHS. Strategies include:

• Adopting National Standards: Mandating and supporting the use of nationally defined data and technical standards across all new system procurements.
• Shared Care Records: Actively participating in and contributing to integrated care systems (ICS) and local health and care records exemplars (LHCREs) to enable seamless information flow between different care providers.
• Open APIs: Encouraging technology vendors to provide open Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) to allow for easier integration and data sharing.
• Leveraging National Digital Infrastructure: Maximising the use of national platforms like the NHS Spine for secure, standardised data exchange.

7.7. Strengthen Clinical and Patient Engagement

Meaningful engagement with clinical staff and patients throughout the digital transformation journey is essential. This means:

• Co-design: Involving end-users from the initial conceptualisation phase to ensure solutions meet real-world needs.
• User-Friendly Interfaces: Prioritising intuitive and efficient user interfaces to minimise learning curves and improve user satisfaction.
• Feedback Loops: Establishing clear channels for staff and patient feedback to continuously refine and improve digital tools.
• Patient Empowerment: Designing digital solutions that genuinely empower patients to manage their health, access information, and interact with services on their own terms, addressing digital inclusion issues for patients.

7.8. Strategic Procurement for Digital Solutions

Reforming procurement processes to be more agile, value-based, and innovation-friendly can significantly accelerate digital adoption. This involves:

• Outcome-Based Procurement: Shifting from a focus on features and lowest cost to procuring solutions based on their ability to deliver defined clinical and operational outcomes.
• Interoperability Mandates: Making interoperability a key requirement in all procurement processes.
• Engaging with SMEs: Creating pathways for innovative small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) to offer their solutions to the NHS.
• Framework Agreements: Utilising national framework agreements that simplify procurement for trusts and offer pre-vetted, high-quality digital solutions.

By systematically implementing these strategies, NHS trusts can collectively elevate their digital maturity, ensuring they are not just adopters of technology but architects of a digitally advanced, patient-centric healthcare future.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

8. Conclusion

Digital maturity represents a critical and multifaceted determinant of the National Health Service’s capacity to effectively implement, integrate, and derive maximum value from innovative medical technologies. While pockets of excellence demonstrate the transformative potential of advanced digital capabilities, a significant and concerning disparity in digital readiness persists across NHS trusts. This variability is not merely an operational inconvenience but a systemic challenge with direct implications for patient outcomes, operational efficiency, and the equitable delivery of high-quality care across the nation.

The journey through the stages of digital development, from initial fragmentation to advanced, data-driven innovation, underscores the profound effort and strategic foresight required. Trusts at lower maturity levels grapple with antiquated infrastructure, profound interoperability challenges, and significant gaps in digital literacy, which collectively impede the successful adoption of new technologies and limit their ability to leverage initiatives designed to streamline innovation, such as the Innovator Passport. Conversely, digitally mature trusts are poised to seamlessly integrate cutting-edge solutions, harness sophisticated data analytics, and drive continuous improvements in patient care, thereby widening the gap between the digitally empowered and the digitally disadvantaged.

Addressing the pervasive barriers to digital transformation—including chronic financial constraints, overwhelming operational pressures, the burden of legacy systems, intractable interoperability issues, and critical digital literacy gaps within the workforce—is not an optional endeavour but an urgent imperative. These obstacles demand a coordinated, sustained, and comprehensive response that transcends individual trust boundaries.

To propel the entire NHS towards a higher plane of digital maturity, a strategic blueprint must be meticulously implemented. This includes developing clear, ambitious digital strategies aligned with national vision, making sustained and ring-fenced investments in modern, scalable, and secure infrastructure, and, crucially, fostering a proactive digital culture that embraces change and empowers its workforce. Furthermore, enhancing training programmes tailored to diverse staff needs, implementing robust data governance frameworks, actively promoting interoperability and standardisation across systems, strengthening clinical and patient engagement, and reforming procurement processes are all indispensable components of this transformation.

Ultimately, the goal is to cultivate a truly learning health system where technology serves as an enabler for continuous improvement, innovation, and equitable access to the best possible care for all. The digital maturity journey is not a destination but an ongoing process of adaptation, investment, and cultural evolution. Only through collective commitment, visionary leadership, and sustained effort can the NHS realise its full digital potential, ensuring it remains a world-leading healthcare provider, fit for the challenges and opportunities of the 21st century.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

References

• Digital Health Technology News. (2022). Digital transformation – managing the barriers to change. Retrieved from https://www.healthtechdigital.com/digital-transformation-managing-the-barriers-to-change/
• Health Foundation. (2024a). Many NHS staff struggle to use electronic records effectively, report finds. Retrieved from https://www.ft.com/content/086dee7e-efb1-4926-9da0-1f70210a5627
• Health Foundation. (2024b). ‘Operating in the Stone Age’: NHS staff’s daily struggle with outdated tech. Retrieved from https://www.ft.com/content/e456bd4c-d7b1-4446-a538-be46bd445166a1
• Information Age. (2022). Top 5 biggest challenges for digital transformation in the NHS. Retrieved from https://www.information-age.com/top-5-biggest-challenges-digital-transformation-nhs-8676/
• Netcall & Davies. (2022). Legacy systems and lack of tech expertise and leadership pose major barriers to NHS transformation. Retrieved from https://www.healthtechdigital.com/legacy-systems-and-lack-of-tech-expertise-and-leadership-pose-major-barriers-to-nhs-transformation/
• NHS England. (2017). Cyber attack on NHS and other organisations – what we know so far. Retrieved from https://www.england.nhs.uk/2017/05/cyber-attack/
• NHS England. (2023a). NHS Long Term Plan. Retrieved from https://www.longtermplan.nhs.uk/
• NHS England. (2023b). Accelerating the adoption of innovation: The Innovator Passport. Retrieved from https://www.england.nhs.uk/innovation/innovator-passport/
• NHS England. (2023c). Digital maturity assessment. Retrieved from https://www.england.nhs.uk/long-read/digital-maturity-assessment/
• NHS England. (2023d). Learning health systems: What they are and how we can achieve them. Retrieved from https://www.england.nhs.uk/digital-healthcare/learning-health-systems/
• NHS England. (2023e). Inclusive digital healthcare: a framework for NHS action on digital inclusion. Retrieved from https://www.england.nhs.uk/long-read/inclusive-digital-healthcare-a-framework-for-nhs-action-on-digital-inclusion/
• NHS Providers. (2024a). Finances are main barrier to digital transformation say NHS leaders. Retrieved from https://www.digitalhealth.net/2024/10/finances-are-main-barrier-digital-transformation-say-nhs-leaders/
• NHS Providers. (2024b). Digital transformation survey 2024: challenges, opportunities and priorities for trust leaders. Retrieved from https://nhsproviders.org/resources/digital-transformation-survey-2024/survey-findings-barriers-and-opportunities
• NHS Providers. (2024c). Digital transformation hampered by budgets, NHS pressures and poor IT infrastructure. Retrieved from https://nhsproviders.org/news/digital-transformation-hampered-by-budgets-nhs-pressures-and-poor-it-infrastructure
• Tech Monitor. (2022). Infrastructure and attitudes hinder NHS digital transformation. Retrieved from https://www.techmonitor.ai/leadership/digital-transformation/digital-transformation-nhs-bt-report-healthcare
• Wikipedia. (2022). Global Digital Exemplar. Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Digital_Exemplar