Abstract
This research report examines the intricate landscape of youth empowerment in Lebanon, moving beyond a superficial assessment of individual organizations to analyze the broader systemic challenges and opportunities that shape their impact. While organizations like GAME Lebanon, ULYP, Anera, and the Lebanon Youth Movement undoubtedly contribute to positive change, this report argues that their effectiveness is significantly influenced by deeper contextual factors. These include Lebanon’s persistent political instability, economic crises, sectarian divisions, brain drain, the legacy of conflict, and the influx of refugees, all of which exacerbate existing vulnerabilities among Lebanese youth. This report investigates the limitations imposed by these structural constraints, explores the challenges of coordination and collaboration within a highly fragmented NGO sector, examines the impact of external funding and political influence, and proposes a more holistic framework for understanding and strengthening youth empowerment initiatives in Lebanon. It emphasizes the need for interventions that address not only immediate needs but also underlying systemic issues, while acknowledging the evolving geopolitical landscape and its implications for youth agency and participation.
Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.
1. Introduction: Youth as a Nexus of Crisis and Opportunity
Lebanon is currently grappling with a multifaceted crisis, characterized by economic collapse, political gridlock, and social fragmentation. Within this context, Lebanese youth (defined here as individuals between the ages of 15 and 35, acknowledging the diverse experiences within this age bracket) represent both a population disproportionately affected by these challenges and a critical resource for the country’s future. High unemployment rates, limited access to quality education and healthcare, and a pervasive sense of hopelessness are driving significant brain drain, with many young Lebanese seeking opportunities abroad (UNDP, 2022). The legacy of conflict, coupled with persistent sectarian tensions, further exacerbates feelings of marginalization and exclusion, particularly among marginalized youth. At the same time, young Lebanese are increasingly politically active, demanding greater accountability from their leaders and advocating for systemic change.
This report argues that understanding youth empowerment in Lebanon requires moving beyond a simple enumeration of the activities of individual organizations. While the contributions of groups like GAME Lebanon (focusing on sports and social inclusion), ULYP (providing scholarships and leadership training), Anera (addressing basic needs and development), and the Lebanon Youth Movement (engaging in advocacy and activism) are undoubtedly valuable, their impact is constrained by broader systemic issues. These organizations often operate in silos, with limited coordination and collaboration, and their programs may not adequately address the root causes of youth vulnerability. Moreover, their reliance on external funding can create dependencies and potentially influence their priorities, potentially skewing their activities away from the more pressing needs of Lebanese youth.
This research aims to provide a more nuanced and critical analysis of the landscape of youth empowerment in Lebanon. It will explore the following key questions:
- How do structural constraints, such as political instability, economic crises, and sectarian divisions, impact the effectiveness of youth empowerment initiatives?
- What are the challenges and opportunities for coordination and collaboration among different organizations working with youth in Lebanon?
- How does the reliance on external funding shape the priorities and activities of these organizations, and what are the potential implications for their long-term sustainability?
- How do broader geopolitical realities, including regional conflicts and international interventions, influence the opportunities and challenges facing Lebanese youth?
- What are the most promising strategies for promoting youth empowerment in Lebanon, taking into account the complex and dynamic context in which these initiatives operate?
Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.
2. Structural Constraints: A Perfect Storm of Challenges
The effectiveness of any youth empowerment initiative in Lebanon is contingent on the broader political, economic, and social environment. Lebanon is facing a confluence of crises that severely limit the opportunities available to young people and undermine the impact of empowerment programs. These structural constraints include:
- Political Instability and Corruption: Lebanon’s political system, characterized by sectarian power-sharing and widespread corruption, has consistently failed to address the country’s pressing needs. Political gridlock, lack of accountability, and clientelism undermine good governance and create an environment of distrust and disillusionment, especially among young people who perceive their voices as unheard. The lack of a stable and functioning government hampers efforts to implement meaningful reforms and provide essential services, such as education and healthcare.
- Economic Crisis: The ongoing economic crisis, characterized by hyperinflation, currency devaluation, and widespread unemployment, has had a devastating impact on Lebanese youth. Many families have lost their savings, and young people struggle to afford basic necessities such as food, housing, and transportation. The economic crisis has also severely limited access to education and healthcare, further exacerbating existing inequalities. The brain drain resulting from the economic crisis poses a significant threat to Lebanon’s future, as young, skilled workers seek opportunities elsewhere.
- Sectarian Divisions: Lebanon’s sectarian divisions continue to be a major source of social and political instability. These divisions are often exploited by political elites to maintain their power, fostering an environment of distrust and animosity. Sectarianism limits opportunities for cross-sectarian cooperation and undermines efforts to build a cohesive national identity. Young people are particularly vulnerable to the influence of sectarian ideologies, which can hinder their ability to engage in critical thinking and challenge existing power structures. This sectarianism also results in fragmented resource allocation, with NGOs often focusing on specific religious communities, thereby failing to provide support across the board.
- Brain Drain: As mentioned previously, the high levels of emigration, primarily among youth, are rapidly decreasing Lebanon’s potential. This is creating a critical skills shortage across various sectors and eroding the nation’s long-term prospects for recovery. It is not just a matter of losing talent, but also a loss of potential innovators and future leaders.
- The Legacy of Conflict and Refugee Crisis: Decades of conflict and political instability have left a legacy of trauma and displacement. The influx of Syrian refugees has further strained Lebanon’s already limited resources and created new tensions between communities. Young people who have experienced violence or displacement are particularly vulnerable to mental health problems and social exclusion. The refugee crisis has also increased competition for jobs and resources, exacerbating existing inequalities. The integration of young refugees into Lebanese society remains a significant challenge.
These structural constraints create a context of chronic instability and uncertainty, undermining the effectiveness of youth empowerment initiatives. Programs that focus solely on skills training or leadership development may not be sufficient to address the root causes of youth vulnerability. A more comprehensive approach is needed that tackles these underlying structural issues and creates a more enabling environment for young people to thrive.
Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.
3. Fragmentation and Coordination: Navigating a Crowded Field
The NGO sector in Lebanon is characterized by a high degree of fragmentation, with numerous organizations operating in different sectors and geographic areas. While this diversity can be seen as a strength, it also creates challenges for coordination and collaboration. Many organizations work in silos, with limited communication and information sharing, leading to duplication of efforts and inefficient use of resources. A lack of central oversight or coordination mechanisms further exacerbates this problem. There are multiple reasons for this fragmentation, including:
- Sectarian Affiliations: Many NGOs in Lebanon are affiliated with specific religious or political groups, which can limit their ability to work with organizations from different backgrounds. These sectarian affiliations can also create biases in the provision of services, with certain communities receiving preferential treatment.
- Competition for Funding: The NGO sector in Lebanon is heavily reliant on external funding, which creates intense competition among organizations. This competition can discourage collaboration and lead to a focus on short-term projects rather than long-term sustainable solutions. Organizations are often incentivized to prioritize their own organizational interests over the needs of the communities they serve.
- Lack of Capacity: Many NGOs in Lebanon lack the capacity to effectively coordinate and collaborate with other organizations. This can be due to a lack of resources, expertise, or leadership. The lack of a clear understanding of the roles and responsibilities of different organizations can also hinder collaboration.
Despite these challenges, there are some examples of successful coordination and collaboration among NGOs in Lebanon. For instance, some networks and consortia have been formed to address specific issues, such as child protection or education. These networks provide a platform for organizations to share information, coordinate activities, and advocate for policy change. However, these efforts are often ad hoc and lack the sustained support needed to achieve significant impact. A more strategic and coordinated approach is needed, involving government agencies, international organizations, and civil society groups.
Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.
4. The Influence of External Funding: Dependency and Distortions
Lebanon’s NGO sector is heavily reliant on external funding from international organizations, foreign governments, and private donors. While this funding is essential for supporting youth empowerment initiatives, it also creates a number of challenges:
- Dependency: Reliance on external funding can make NGOs dependent on donor priorities and agendas. This can limit their ability to respond to the specific needs of the communities they serve and undermine their long-term sustainability. NGOs may be forced to implement projects that align with donor interests, even if they are not the most effective or appropriate solutions.
- Distortions: External funding can also distort the priorities of the NGO sector, leading to an overemphasis on certain issues or geographic areas. For example, donors may be more likely to fund projects that focus on refugees or conflict resolution, while neglecting other important issues such as education or healthcare. This can create imbalances in the provision of services and exacerbate existing inequalities.
- Political Influence: External funding can be used to exert political influence in Lebanon, with donors supporting NGOs that align with their own political agendas. This can undermine the independence and impartiality of the NGO sector and create divisions within civil society. NGOs may be pressured to support certain political parties or candidates in exchange for funding.
- Lack of Accountability: External funding can also lead to a lack of accountability, as NGOs are primarily accountable to their donors rather than to the communities they serve. This can result in a lack of transparency and a failure to address the needs and concerns of local populations. NGOs may be tempted to prioritize reporting requirements and donor expectations over the actual impact of their programs.
To mitigate these challenges, it is essential to diversify funding sources and promote greater financial sustainability within the NGO sector. This can be achieved through building local fundraising capacity, developing social enterprises, and advocating for government funding for civil society organizations. NGOs also need to be more transparent and accountable to the communities they serve, ensuring that their programs are aligned with local needs and priorities.
Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.
5. Geopolitical Realities: Regional Conflicts and International Interventions
Lebanon’s geopolitical context significantly shapes the opportunities and challenges facing young people. The country is located in a volatile region, facing ongoing conflicts, political instability, and external interference. These factors can undermine youth empowerment initiatives and create new vulnerabilities. The ongoing conflicts in Syria, Yemen, and Palestine have had a direct impact on Lebanon, with the influx of refugees straining resources and exacerbating social tensions. The involvement of regional powers, such as Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Turkey, in Lebanese politics further complicates the situation, with these actors often supporting different factions and exacerbating sectarian divisions. International interventions, such as the presence of UN peacekeeping forces and the provision of humanitarian aid, can also have unintended consequences, potentially undermining local ownership and creating dependencies.
Moreover, global trends such as climate change and economic globalization also impact Lebanese youth. Climate change poses a significant threat to Lebanon’s environment and economy, with droughts, floods, and rising sea levels potentially displacing communities and undermining livelihoods. Economic globalization can create new opportunities for young people, such as access to global markets and technologies, but it can also exacerbate inequalities and create new forms of exploitation. Young people need to be equipped with the skills and knowledge to navigate these complex geopolitical realities and advocate for their interests on a global stage. Therefore, youth empowerment programs must incorporate a robust component of critical thinking about international relations, the roles of transnational corporations, and the impacts of globalization.
Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.
6. Promising Strategies for Youth Empowerment: A Holistic Approach
Given the complex and multifaceted challenges facing Lebanese youth, a holistic and integrated approach to youth empowerment is needed. This approach should address not only immediate needs but also underlying structural issues, promoting long-term sustainable solutions. Some promising strategies include:
- Investing in Education and Skills Development: Providing access to quality education and vocational training is essential for equipping young people with the skills and knowledge they need to succeed in the labor market. This includes investing in teacher training, curriculum development, and infrastructure improvements. It also requires addressing the specific needs of marginalized youth, such as refugees and young people with disabilities. Furthermore, promoting digital literacy and entrepreneurship skills can enable young people to participate in the global economy.
- Promoting Civic Engagement and Political Participation: Empowering young people to participate in civic life and political decision-making is crucial for building a more democratic and accountable society. This includes supporting youth-led initiatives, promoting youth representation in government, and advocating for policies that address the needs and concerns of young people. It also requires fostering critical thinking skills and media literacy to enable young people to engage in informed and constructive dialogue.
- Addressing Mental Health and Well-being: Providing access to mental health services and promoting psychosocial support is essential for addressing the trauma and stress experienced by many young people in Lebanon. This includes training mental health professionals, raising awareness about mental health issues, and destigmatizing mental illness. It also requires addressing the social determinants of mental health, such as poverty, inequality, and discrimination.
- Supporting Entrepreneurship and Job Creation: Creating opportunities for young people to start their own businesses and find meaningful employment is essential for promoting economic empowerment. This includes providing access to finance, mentorship, and business training. It also requires creating a more enabling environment for entrepreneurship, reducing bureaucratic barriers, and promoting innovation.
- Strengthening Social Cohesion and Inter-Sectarian Dialogue: Promoting social cohesion and fostering inter-sectarian dialogue is crucial for building a more inclusive and harmonious society. This includes supporting cross-community initiatives, promoting cultural exchange, and addressing the root causes of sectarian tensions. It also requires challenging hate speech and discrimination and promoting respect for diversity.
- Strengthening Governance and Accountability: Promoting good governance and accountability is essential for creating a more just and equitable society. This includes strengthening the rule of law, combating corruption, and promoting transparency and participation in decision-making. It also requires holding public officials accountable for their actions and ensuring that the rights of all citizens are protected.
These strategies should be implemented in a coordinated and integrated manner, involving government agencies, international organizations, civil society groups, and the private sector. A participatory approach is needed, ensuring that young people are actively involved in the design, implementation, and evaluation of youth empowerment initiatives. A long-term commitment is essential, as sustainable change requires sustained investment and effort.
Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.
7. Conclusion: Reimagining Youth Empowerment in a Shifting Landscape
Youth empowerment in Lebanon is a complex and multifaceted challenge, shaped by a confluence of structural constraints, geopolitical realities, and internal dynamics. While organizations like GAME Lebanon, ULYP, Anera, and the Lebanon Youth Movement undoubtedly play a valuable role, their impact is limited by these broader contextual factors. This research has argued that a more holistic and integrated approach is needed, one that addresses not only immediate needs but also underlying systemic issues. This requires strengthening governance, promoting social cohesion, investing in education and skills development, addressing mental health and well-being, and supporting entrepreneurship and job creation.
Moving forward, it is essential to recognize the agency and resilience of Lebanese youth. They are not merely victims of circumstance but active agents of change, demanding greater accountability from their leaders and advocating for a better future. Youth empowerment initiatives should empower young people to exercise their rights, participate in decision-making, and shape their own destinies. This requires creating spaces for dialogue, fostering critical thinking, and promoting leadership skills. It also requires recognizing the diverse experiences and perspectives of young people, ensuring that all voices are heard and valued.
Finally, the evolving geopolitical landscape presents both challenges and opportunities for youth empowerment in Lebanon. Regional conflicts and international interventions can undermine progress, but they can also create new avenues for collaboration and innovation. By embracing a more strategic and coordinated approach, and by empowering young people to become active citizens, Lebanon can harness the potential of its youth and build a more prosperous and equitable future.
Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.
References
UNDP (United Nations Development Programme). (2022). Lebanon: Youth Needs Assessment. UNDP Lebanon.
[Other relevant sources will be added here based on further research. Examples of sources to be consulted include:
- Academic articles on youth development, social movements, and political participation in Lebanon.
- Reports from international organizations (e.g., World Bank, UNICEF, UNHCR) on Lebanon’s economic and social situation.
- Publications from Lebanese research centers and think tanks on youth issues.
- Websites and social media accounts of organizations working with youth in Lebanon.
- News articles and media reports on current events in Lebanon.]
Be the first to comment