The Shahbazim: A Comprehensive Analysis of Their Role, Training, and Impact in the Green House Model of Elder Care

Abstract

The Shahbazim stand as cornerstone figures within the innovative Green House model of elder care, embodying a radical departure from conventional caregiving paradigms. As multi-skilled universal caregivers, their responsibilities extend far beyond the typical scope of traditional direct care roles, encompassing comprehensive personal care, meticulous meal preparation, diligent household management, and, crucially, the cultivation of profound, enduring relationships with residents. This comprehensive research report undertakes an exhaustive examination of the Shahbazim’s multifaceted role within the Green House model. It delves deeply into their rigorous training and continuous professional development pathways, conducts an extensive comparative analysis against established traditional caregiver roles, scrutinizing their respective impacts on resident outcomes and staff well-being, and thoroughly assesses the feasibility and inherent challenges associated with integrating this transformative model into broader, often entrenched, long-term care systems. Through this detailed exploration, the report aims to illuminate the profound implications of empowering direct care workers to foster genuinely person-centered, homelike environments.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

1. Introduction: Reimagining Elder Care Through Culture Change

The landscape of long-term elder care has long been dominated by the traditional nursing home model, a system that, despite its foundational intent, has faced persistent criticism for its institutional characteristics and often rigid, hierarchical staffing structures. This conventional approach has frequently been associated with the provision of impersonal, task-oriented care, inadvertently leading to a diminished quality of life for residents, a pervasive sense of disempowerment among direct care staff, and an environment that often prioritizes clinical efficiency over individual dignity and personal preference. Such criticisms highlight a pressing need for fundamental reform, moving beyond incremental improvements to embrace transformative models of care delivery [Zimmerman, Shier, & Saliba, 2014].

In direct response to these profound systemic challenges and a growing advocacy for person-centered care, the Green House model emerged as a revolutionary alternative. Conceived as a radical rethinking of long-term care environments, its fundamental aim is to dismantle the vestiges of institutionalization and cultivate genuinely homelike settings that steadfastly emphasize resident autonomy, highly personalized care, and robust staff empowerment. At the very core of this paradigm shift are the Shahbazim, a dedicated team of universal caregivers whose comprehensive range of responsibilities and empowered operational framework fundamentally redefine the caregiving role in long-term care. The name ‘Shahbaz,’ derived from the Persian term for a royal falcon, symbolically captures the agility, acuity, and elevated status of these caregivers, distinguishing them significantly from their counterparts in conventional settings.

This report aims to provide an expansive and in-depth exploration of the Shahbazim concept, elucidating their operational framework, the philosophy underpinning their unique role, and the measurable impacts they exert on the entire care ecosystem. By detailing their rigorous training, comparing their efficacy with traditional roles, and dissecting the practicalities of integrating this model more broadly, we seek to underscore the profound potential of reimagining direct care work as a skilled, empowered, and deeply relational profession.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

2. The Green House Model: A Paradigm Shift in Long-Term Care

The Green House model represents a deliberate and comprehensive person-centered approach to elder care, meticulously designed to counteract the depersonalizing effects of traditional institutional settings. Its overarching vision is to provide a ‘real home’ for residents, cultivate a ‘meaningful life’ brimming with purpose and engagement, and foster an ’empowered staff’ capable of delivering high-quality, individualized care with autonomy and professional satisfaction. This philosophy, initially conceived by Dr. Bill Thomas, challenges the conventional medical model of care by placing residents’ psycho-social well-being on par with their clinical needs, striving for a holistic approach that nurtures mind, body, and spirit [Cohen et al., 2016].

2.1. Architectural and Environmental Design Principles

A defining characteristic of the Green House model is its innovative architectural design, which fundamentally departs from the sprawling, often sterile, corridors of typical nursing homes. Each Green House is a small, self-contained residential-style home, purposefully built or renovated to accommodate a compact community of usually 10 to 12 residents. This intimate scale is critical, as it fosters a genuine sense of family and belonging, a stark contrast to the anonymity often experienced in larger facilities.

Key design features include:

• Private Rooms with Attached Bathrooms: Every resident enjoys the privacy and dignity of their own room, complete with an en-suite bathroom. This design element directly addresses a core complaint about traditional nursing homes where shared rooms are common, ensuring personal space and enhancing individual autonomy.
• Open Kitchen, Dining, and Living Spaces: These common areas are the vibrant heart of each Green House. The open-plan kitchen is fully functional, designed for active use by Shahbazim and often residents themselves, promoting sensory engagement through the aromas of home cooking. The communal dining table is not merely a place for meals but a central hub for social interaction, fostering a sense of shared community and daily routine akin to a family home. Living spaces are comfortable and inviting, encouraging relaxation, conversation, and participation in various activities.
• De-institutionalized Aesthetics: The interior design intentionally avoids clinical aesthetics, opting instead for comfortable furnishings, natural lighting, and personalized decor that reflects the preferences of the residents. This creates an environment that feels familiar, safe, and genuinely homelike.
• Accessibility and Safety: While promoting a homelike atmosphere, the design incorporates discreet accessibility features and safety measures, ensuring residents can move freely and securely, reducing risks of falls while maintaining a non-institutional feel.
• The ‘Hearth’ or ‘Den’ Concept: Many Green Houses include a cozy ‘hearth’ or ‘den’ area, often with a fireplace, serving as an additional intimate gathering space where residents can relax, read, or engage in quiet conversation, further enhancing the sense of home.

This intentional design serves to de-medicalize the environment, promoting normalcy and encouraging residents to maintain their routines and social connections, which are vital components of a meaningful life.

2.2. Self-Managed Work Teams and Staff Empowerment

Another foundational pillar of the Green House model is the concept of self-managed work teams. Unlike the rigid, hierarchical staffing structures prevalent in traditional long-term care where tasks are compartmentalized and authority flows from the top down, the Shahbazim operate as a cohesive, autonomous unit within each home. This structure is deliberately designed to promote autonomy, accountability, and a collective sense of ownership over the residents’ well-being and the home’s smooth operation.

In practice, self-managed teams entail:

• Shared Decision-Making: Shahbazim collectively make decisions regarding daily routines, resident activities, menu planning, and even conflict resolution within the home, often with guidance from a clinical nurse and a ‘Guide’ (a team leader or mentor). This empowers them to tailor care to the immediate needs and preferences of residents, fostering a responsive and flexible environment.
• Cross-Functional Responsibilities: Team members are cross-trained and expected to perform a wide array of tasks traditionally divided among different departments (e.g., nursing assistants, dietary staff, housekeeping). This eliminates silos and ensures a seamless flow of care and household operations.
• Flexible Scheduling: Teams often have input into their own scheduling, allowing for greater work-life balance and a sense of control over their professional lives, which contributes to higher job satisfaction and lower turnover.
• Accountability: With empowerment comes accountability. The team is collectively responsible for the well-being of the residents and the maintenance of the home, fostering a strong sense of shared purpose and peer support.

This empowerment directly addresses a core failing of traditional models: the disempowerment and deskilling of direct care workers. By elevating their role, the Green House model acknowledges that those closest to the residents are best positioned to understand and respond to their needs, leading to more immediate, personalized, and effective care [Reinhard et al., 2022].

2.3. Comprehensive Care Responsibilities and Holistic Living

The Shahbazim’s responsibilities are intentionally comprehensive, ensuring holistic care that addresses not only the physical but also the emotional, social, and spiritual needs of residents. Their role transcends mere task completion, focusing instead on fostering genuine relationships and integrating care seamlessly into the fabric of daily life within the home. This integrated approach ensures that care is not an interruption to life but an inherent part of a meaningful existence.

This approach contrasts sharply with other culture change models like the Eden Alternative, which focuses on eliminating the ‘three plagues’ of loneliness, helplessness, and boredom through plants, animals, and children, or the Pioneer Network, which advocates for widespread culture change in existing facilities. While sharing common philosophical ground, the Green House model uniquely combines specific architectural design with an empowered, universal caregiver role, making the Shahbazim integral to its distinct identity and success [Bowers et al., 2016].

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

3. The Multifaceted Role of Shahbazim in the Green House Model

The Shahbazim are the living embodiment of the Green House philosophy, serving not merely as caregivers but as companions, advocates, and active contributors to the vibrancy of each home. Their duties are interwoven to create an integrated daily experience for residents, fostering independence and personal dignity. Their unique designation, ‘Shahbaz,’ signifying a royal falcon, underscores their elevated skill set, keen observation, and unwavering commitment, moving beyond the functional label of a ‘CNA’ to acknowledge their comprehensive expertise and vital role in the residents’ lives.

3.1. Personalized Clinical and Personal Care

At the core of the Shahbazim’s responsibilities is the provision of assistance with activities of daily living (ADLs), such as bathing, dressing, grooming, eating, and mobility support. However, this is delivered with a profound emphasis on personalization and respect for individual preferences. The Shahbazim are trained to:

• Tailor Care to Individual Rhythms: Rather than adhering to rigid schedules, Shahbazim adapt care routines to residents’ preferred waking times, meal times, and activity preferences, promoting a sense of control and normalcy.
• Promote Independence: They employ restorative care techniques, encouraging residents to do as much for themselves as possible, providing ‘just enough’ assistance to maintain dignity and preserve functional abilities, rather than ‘doing for’ them.
• Dignity and Respect: All personal care is delivered with utmost respect for privacy and personal dignity, fostering a trusting relationship between caregiver and resident. This includes understanding cultural and personal sensitivities related to intimate care.
• Clinical Observation and Reporting: While not licensed nurses, Shahbazim receive advanced training to meticulously observe and document changes in residents’ physical and mental status, vital signs, skin integrity, pain levels, and any deviations from baseline. They act as the ‘eyes and ears’ of the clinical team, promptly communicating concerns to the nurse, who provides clinical oversight and intervenes as necessary. This early detection capability is crucial for preventing hospitalizations and managing acute conditions proactively.
• Assistance with Medication Management (under supervision): In many Green House homes, Shahbazim may be trained to assist with medication reminders or, in some states, administer routine medications under the direct supervision and delegation of a licensed nurse, further broadening their impact on resident health management.

3.2. Culinary Arts and Nurturing Through Food

Food preparation is elevated from a functional task to a cornerstone of daily life and social interaction within the Green House model. Shahbazim are proficient in culinary arts, responsible for:

• Meal Planning and Preparation: They plan menus collaboratively with residents, incorporating dietary restrictions, cultural preferences, and individual tastes. Meals are prepared fresh daily in the open kitchen, allowing residents to witness and often participate in the process, stimulating appetite and engagement. This contrasts with institutional food service where meals are often prepared off-site and delivered en masse.
• Nutritional Support: Shahbazim monitor residents’ nutritional intake, identify changes in appetite, and prepare appealing, nutritious meals and snacks tailored to specific health needs (e.g., modified textures, diabetic-friendly options). They understand the link between good nutrition and overall health outcomes.
• Communal Dining: Meals are shared at a common dining table, creating a family-style atmosphere. This promotes social interaction, conversation, and a sense of belonging, combating isolation. Shahbazim dine with residents, further blurring the lines between staff and family, fostering natural engagement.
• Therapeutic Benefits: The act of cooking and the aromas emanating from the kitchen can evoke pleasant memories, reduce anxiety, and stimulate cognitive engagement, especially for residents with dementia. Resident involvement, even in simple tasks like setting the table or stirring, offers purpose and continued connection to daily life.

3.3. Household Management and Creating a True Home

Beyond personal care and meals, Shahbazim are integral to maintaining the physical environment of the Green House, ensuring it remains a comfortable, safe, and genuinely homelike space. Their responsibilities include:

• Cleaning and Organization: They manage daily cleaning tasks, laundry, and maintaining general order within the home, ensuring cleanliness standards are met while maintaining a relaxed, non-institutional feel. This includes understanding infection control protocols within a homelike context.
• Resident Participation: Residents are encouraged to participate in household chores to the extent of their abilities and preferences, whether folding laundry, watering plants, or helping with meal preparation. This fosters a sense of ownership and contribution, making the home truly theirs.
• Safety and Maintenance Checks: Shahbazim are trained to conduct routine safety checks, identify maintenance issues (e.g., a leaking faucet, a faulty light bulb), and report them promptly. Their continuous presence ensures immediate attention to environmental concerns.
• Creating Atmosphere: This role extends beyond mere cleanliness to actively creating a pleasant and personalized atmosphere. This might involve decorating for holidays, arranging flowers, or playing music that residents enjoy, all contributing to the emotional comfort of the home.

3.4. Deep Relationship Building and Psychosocial Support

Perhaps the most distinctive and impactful aspect of the Shahbazim’s role is their profound emphasis on relationship building. Unlike traditional models where caregivers may rotate frequently, Shahbazim provide continuity of care, working consistently with the same small group of residents. This allows them to:

• Develop Deep Bonds: Over time, Shahbazim develop deep, meaningful relationships with residents, understanding their unique personalities, life histories, preferences, routines, and idiosyncrasies. This intimate knowledge is essential for truly personalized care.
• Emotional and Psychosocial Support: They offer emotional support, companionship, and engage in meaningful activities tailored to individual interests. This directly combats feelings of loneliness, boredom, and helplessness often prevalent in institutional settings. They become trusted confidants and advocates.
• Understanding Life Stories: Shahbazim actively engage residents in conversations about their past, their experiences, and their families, using this knowledge to inform care delivery and foster a sense of identity and continuity. This narrative approach to care is fundamental to person-centered practice.
• Advocacy: By intimately knowing their residents, Shahbazim become powerful advocates for their choices and preferences, ensuring their voices are heard within the care team and with their families.
• Spiritual and Cultural Responsiveness: They are attuned to residents’ spiritual and cultural needs, facilitating access to religious services, culturally significant foods, or traditions, further enhancing the meaningfulness of daily life.

3.5. Team Collaboration and Communication

Shahbazim operate within a highly collaborative framework, interacting closely with other Green House staff, particularly the clinical nurse (who provides overall clinical supervision and coordination), and the ‘Guide’ or ‘Sage’ (who offers mentorship and team facilitation). They participate in daily huddles and regular team meetings, sharing observations, discussing care plans, and collaboratively problem-solving. This interdisciplinary approach ensures that the holistic view of the resident held by the Shahbazim is integrated into all aspects of their care, fostering a truly comprehensive and responsive support system.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

4. Training and Professional Development of Shahbazim: Cultivating Expertise

The effectiveness and profound impact of the Shahbazim model are inextricably linked to the comprehensive and continuous training and professional development pathways they undertake. This rigorous preparation significantly transcends the standard requirements for traditional Certified Nursing Assistants (CNAs), equipping Shahbazim with a diverse and advanced skill set necessary to manage their broad responsibilities and embody the Green House philosophy [Reinhard et al., 2022].

4.1. Pre-requisites and Selection Process

The recruitment of Shahbazim is a deliberate and selective process. Beyond basic educational requirements, candidates are typically screened for qualities such as:

• Empathy and Compassion: A genuine desire to connect with and care for elders.
• Strong Interpersonal Skills: The ability to communicate effectively, build rapport, and resolve conflicts respectfully.
• Initiative and Problem-Solving: A proactive attitude and the capacity to think critically and make decisions within a self-managed team framework.
• Adaptability and Openness to Learning: Willingness to embrace new skills and a broader scope of practice, moving beyond traditional task-oriented roles.
• Teamwork Orientation: An understanding of and commitment to collaborative work.

Initial assessments often include behavioral interviews and scenarios designed to evaluate these core competencies, recognizing that personal attributes are as crucial as technical skills for success in this role.

4.2. Initial Comprehensive Training Program

The initial training program for Shahbazim is intensive, typically spanning several weeks and often exceeding 200 hours, significantly more than the federally mandated 75 hours for CNAs. It is structured to provide both theoretical knowledge and extensive hands-on experience, often incorporating classroom instruction, simulated environments, and supervised practical application within a Green House setting. Key training modules include:

• Advanced Clinical Skills: While not replacing the role of a licensed nurse, Shahbazim receive enhanced training in clinical observation, basic nursing skills, and health monitoring. This includes:

  • Accurate measurement and interpretation of vital signs (temperature, pulse, respiration, blood pressure).
  • Observation and documentation of changes in skin integrity, including early signs of pressure ulcers.
  • Assistance with mobility, transfers, and use of assistive devices, with a focus on fall prevention techniques.
  • Understanding and identifying symptoms of common chronic conditions (e.g., diabetes, heart failure, respiratory issues) and acute changes (e.g., signs of infection, dehydration, stroke).
  • Basic first aid and emergency response protocols.
  • Medication reminders and, in some jurisdictions, training for delegated medication administration under strict nursing supervision.
  • Specialized dementia care training, focusing on communication strategies, behavioral intervention techniques, and creating a supportive environment for individuals with cognitive impairments.

• Culinary Arts and Nutrition: This module equips Shahbazim with the skills to manage a household kitchen and provide nutritious meals:

  • Menu planning, incorporating dietary restrictions, cultural preferences, and food allergies.
  • Safe food handling, preparation, and storage practices, adhering to food safety regulations.
  • Basic nutrition principles for older adults, including hydration management.
  • Budgeting and inventory management for food supplies.
  • Therapeutic communication techniques to encourage eating and address appetite changes.

• Household Management and Environmental Stewardship: Training covers the practicalities of maintaining a safe, clean, and comfortable home:

  • Effective and safe cleaning protocols, including infection control measures appropriate for a residential setting.
  • Laundry management, respecting residents’ clothing and preferences.
  • Basic home maintenance identification and reporting.
  • Creating a personalized and aesthetically pleasing living environment.

• Communication and Relationship Building: This is a critical component, moving beyond basic communication to foster deep, empathic connections:

  • Active listening and empathic communication techniques.
  • Conflict resolution strategies for interacting with residents, families, and team members.
  • Understanding resident life histories and preferences to provide truly individualized care.
  • Techniques for engaging residents in meaningful activities, leisure pursuits, and decision-making.
  • Cultural competency and sensitivity to diverse backgrounds.
  • Grief and loss support for residents and their families.

• Self-Management Team Skills: Shahbazim are trained in the principles of self-direction, equipping them to function effectively as an autonomous team:

  • Consensus-building and shared decision-making processes.
  • Problem-solving and conflict resolution within the team.
  • Scheduling, task delegation, and peer accountability.
  • Basic leadership skills and understanding group dynamics.
  • Documentation and reporting protocols consistent with team-based care.

4.3. Continuous Professional Development and Mentorship

The commitment to excellence does not end with initial training. Green House providers emphasize continuous professional development to ensure Shahbazim remain proficient, adapt to new best practices, and continue to grow in their roles:

• Ongoing Education: Regular workshops, seminars, and in-service training sessions are provided on topics such as advanced dementia care, palliative care principles, specialized therapeutic communication, and updates on regulatory changes.
• Peer Learning and Support: Shahbazim frequently engage in peer learning opportunities, sharing experiences, challenges, and successful strategies within their teams and across different Green Houses. Regular team debriefing sessions facilitate reflective practice and mutual support.
• Mentorship by Guides and Sages: Experienced staff members, often referred to as ‘Guides’ (team facilitators) or ‘Sages’ (experienced mentors), play a crucial role. They provide ongoing guidance, support, and coaching, helping Shahbazim navigate complex situations, develop new skills, and strengthen team dynamics. Guides typically have a deeper understanding of team facilitation and conflict resolution, while Sages bring extensive clinical and experiential wisdom.
• Specialization and Certification: Opportunities for Shahbazim to pursue specialized certifications (e.g., certified dementia practitioner, wound care associate) are often supported, allowing them to deepen their expertise in specific areas of interest or need.
• Self-Reflection and Feedback: A culture of continuous improvement is fostered through regular opportunities for self-assessment and constructive feedback, both from peers and mentors.

This robust and ongoing investment in their human capital underscores the Green House model’s recognition of the Shahbazim not as mere functionaries, but as highly skilled professionals whose expertise is central to delivering superior, person-centered elder care.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

5. Comparative Analysis: Shahbazim vs. Traditional Caregiver Roles

The distinctions between the Shahbazim role within the Green House model and traditional caregiver roles are profound, extending beyond mere job descriptions to encompass significant differences in job satisfaction, care quality, and the psychological well-being of both staff and residents. This comparative analysis highlights why the Shahbazim model represents a transformative approach to direct care [Afendulis et al., 2016].

5.1. Scope of Practice and Autonomy

• Traditional Caregivers (e.g., CNAs): In conventional nursing homes, the role of a CNA is often narrowly defined and task-oriented. Responsibilities are typically limited to basic personal care (ADLs) and vital sign monitoring. Tasks are often fragmented, with different staff members (e.g., dietary aides, housekeepers, activity assistants) responsible for specific duties. Decision-making authority is highly centralized, residing with licensed nurses or supervisors, leaving little autonomy for direct care workers. This hierarchical structure can lead to a sense of disempowerment and deskilling.
• Shahbazim: The Shahbazim role is characterized by an expansive scope of practice, integrating personal care, meal preparation, household management, social engagement, and clinical observation. They operate as universal caregivers within a self-managed team framework, possessing significant autonomy to make day-to-day decisions regarding resident care, activities, and household operations. This empowerment allows for immediate, flexible, and personalized responses to resident needs, unconstrained by rigid departmental silos or bureaucratic approvals. As Reinhard et al. (2022) point out, this ’empowered direct care worker’ model fundamentally shifts the power dynamic.

5.2. Job Satisfaction and Turnover Rates

• Traditional Caregivers: High job dissatisfaction and notoriously high turnover rates are endemic to the traditional long-term care sector. Factors contributing to this include low wages, heavy workloads, lack of respect, limited opportunities for advancement, emotional burnout, and a feeling of being undervalued and disempowered. These issues create a revolving door of staff, impacting care continuity and quality.
• Shahbazim: Research consistently indicates that Shahbazim report significantly higher job satisfaction and consequently exhibit lower turnover rates compared to their traditional counterparts [Cohen et al., 2016; Reinhard et al., 2022]. The enhanced autonomy, respect, broader scope of responsibilities, opportunities for continuous learning, and the ability to form deep, meaningful relationships with residents contribute substantially to professional fulfillment. The self-managed team structure fosters a supportive peer environment, reducing feelings of isolation and increasing a sense of belonging and collective purpose. While Shahbazim wages may be slightly higher due to expanded responsibilities, the economic benefits of reduced turnover (lower recruitment and training costs) often offset these expenses.

5.3. Impact on Care Quality and Resident Outcomes

The comprehensive and personalized care model facilitated by Shahbazim leads to demonstrable improvements in both the quality of care and quantifiable health outcomes for residents.

• Reduced Hospitalizations: Studies have shown that residents in Green House homes experience lower rates of hospitalization and emergency room visits compared to those in traditional nursing homes [Afendulis et al., 2016]. This is largely attributable to the Shahbazim’s consistent presence, intimate knowledge of residents, and advanced observational skills, allowing for early detection of subtle changes in condition and prompt intervention by the clinical nurse, preventing minor issues from escalating.
• Improved Health Status: Residents often exhibit improved functional status, including better mobility and fewer pressure ulcers, due to personalized attention, encouragement of physical activity, and proactive skin care by Shahbazim.
• Reduced Psychotropic Medication Use: The focus on individualized care, meaningful engagement, and a calm, familiar environment helps reduce agitation and behavioral challenges, leading to a decreased reliance on psychotropic medications.
• Enhanced Quality of Life: Beyond clinical metrics, residents report a higher quality of life, characterized by increased choice and control over their daily routines, greater social engagement, reduced loneliness and boredom, and a stronger sense of purpose and belonging. The homelike environment and continuous presence of familiar caregivers contribute significantly to emotional well-being.
• Continuity of Care: The consistent assignment of Shahbazim to a small group of residents fosters intimate knowledge and trust, leading to more responsive and effective care planning that genuinely reflects resident preferences and needs.

5.4. Psychological Well-Being of Staff and Residents

The close, enduring relationships fostered within the Green House model benefit the psychological well-being of both Shahbazim and residents.

• For Residents: They experience a profound reduction in feelings of loneliness and isolation, a common affliction in institutional settings. The constant presence of familiar, caring individuals, coupled with meaningful engagement and opportunities for social interaction, contributes to a greater sense of security, belonging, and emotional contentment. Residents feel ‘known’ and valued as individuals, not merely as patients or tasks.
• For Shahbazim: The ability to form deep, reciprocal relationships with residents is a significant source of professional fulfillment and meaning. This connection combats compassion fatigue and burnout often associated with emotionally demanding caregiving roles. Shahbazim report feeling respected, valued, and genuinely connected to their work, translating into higher morale and a stronger sense of purpose. The empowerment to make decisions and directly impact residents’ lives creates a positive feedback loop, reinforcing their commitment and dedication.

In essence, the Green House model, through the Shahbazim, fundamentally shifts the narrative of long-term care from one of institutionalized decline to one of vibrant, person-centered living, simultaneously elevating the status and impact of the direct care workforce.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

6. Feasibility and Challenges of Integrating the Shahbazim Model into Broader Healthcare Systems

While the Green House model and the Shahbazim role offer compelling benefits, their widespread integration into broader healthcare systems presents a complex array of challenges spanning regulatory, financial, workforce, and cultural domains. These hurdles require careful consideration and strategic planning to overcome.

6.1. Regulatory Hurdles and Scope of Practice

• State and Federal Licensing: Current long-term care regulations are largely structured around the traditional institutional model, dictating specific staffing ratios, facility design, and compartmentalized roles (e.g., licensed nurses, CNAs, dietary staff, housekeepers). The Shahbazim’s expanded, universal caregiver role, encompassing multiple traditional functions, often does not fit neatly into existing regulatory frameworks. Adjustments may be required in state licensing laws to formally recognize and permit the Shahbazim’s broader scope of practice, particularly concerning delegated tasks such as medication assistance or enhanced clinical observations.
• Facility Design and Construction: The small, homelike design of Green Houses, with private rooms and common living spaces, differs significantly from standard nursing home construction codes. Obtaining approvals for new construction or substantial renovations to mimic the Green House layout can be challenging and costly, requiring variances or amendments to existing building codes.
• Staffing Ratios: While the Green House model emphasizes consistent staffing by a smaller, highly skilled team, some state regulations mandate specific minimum staffing ratios for different categories of staff (e.g., licensed nurses per resident, CNA hours per resident) that may not align perfectly with the fluid, cross-functional nature of Shahbazim work. Advocacy is often needed to demonstrate that the quality of care delivered by an empowered Shahbazim team meets or exceeds regulatory standards despite unconventional ratios.

6.2. Financial Investment and Sustainability

• Initial Capital Costs: Establishing a Green House model, whether through new construction or extensive renovation, entails significant upfront capital investment. The design emphasizes smaller homes, often resulting in a higher per-bed construction cost compared to large, institutional facilities. This can be a deterrent for organizations with limited capital budgets.
• Training Costs: The comprehensive and advanced training program for Shahbazim is more extensive and therefore more expensive than standard CNA training. This initial investment in human capital requires a robust financial commitment.
• Compensation Structures: To attract and retain highly skilled Shahbazim, compensation often needs to be more competitive than traditional CNA wages, reflecting their expanded responsibilities and professional development. While this contributes to higher staff satisfaction and lower turnover in the long run, it represents a higher immediate labor cost.
• Reimbursement Models: Current long-term care reimbursement systems, particularly Medicaid and Medicare, are often structured to pay for services based on a medical model (e.g., skilled nursing days, specific clinical interventions) rather than a holistic, person-centered model. This can make it challenging for Green House homes to fully capture and be reimbursed for the added value and improved resident outcomes (e.g., fewer hospitalizations) that characterize their model, potentially impacting financial sustainability. Advocacy efforts are continuously underway to align reimbursement with quality outcomes and innovative care delivery.

6.3. Workforce Readiness and Recruitment Challenges

• Finding the Right Talent: Recruiting individuals with the inherent qualities (empathy, initiative, teamwork) and willingness to embrace a multi-skilled, autonomous role is crucial. Many traditional caregivers are accustomed to task-oriented work and a hierarchical structure, and adapting to the Green House philosophy requires a significant mindset shift.
• Overcoming Resistance from Existing Staff: In organizations transitioning from traditional models, there can be resistance from current staff members (e.g., existing CNAs, dietary staff, housekeepers) who may fear that their specialized roles will be eliminated or diminished. This necessitates careful change management, clear communication, and opportunities for retraining or redeployment.
• Scaling Up Training: Developing and delivering the intensive Shahbazim training program on a large scale across multiple facilities requires significant resources, experienced trainers, and standardized curricula. Ensuring consistent quality of training across a broader system is a substantial logistical challenge.

6.4. Cultural and Organizational Transformation

• Resistance to Change: Shifting from entrenched hierarchical models to a self-managed, empowered workforce represents a profound cultural and organizational change. This often faces resistance from various stakeholders, including middle management, long-tenured staff, and even some residents and families accustomed to the traditional ‘hospital-like’ setting.
• Leadership Commitment: Successful integration demands unwavering commitment from organizational leadership – from the board of directors to executive management. Leaders must champion the culture change, provide resources, and actively support the empowerment of Shahbazim and self-managed teams, which often means relinquishing some traditional control.
• Breaking Down Silos: The Green House model intentionally breaks down departmental silos. This requires a significant re-engineering of operational processes and a shift in mindset from ‘this is my job’ to ‘this is our home,’ fostering interdisciplinary collaboration and communication.
• Managing Power Dynamics: Empowering Shahbazim means a redistribution of power. Licensed nurses, for example, transition from a purely supervisory role to a more consultative and supportive role within the team, requiring adjustments in professional identity and practice.

6.5. Measuring Success and Demonstrating Value

• Robust Metrics: To justify the investment and overcome resistance, organizations need robust metrics that effectively demonstrate the benefits of the Shahbazim model beyond anecdotal evidence. This includes tracking not only clinical outcomes but also quality of life indicators, resident satisfaction, staff retention, and economic efficiencies from reduced hospitalizations and staff turnover.
• Longitudinal Research: Continued longitudinal research is essential to further quantify the long-term impact on resident health, staff well-being, and cost-effectiveness, providing empirical evidence for policy makers and potential adopters.

Despite these considerable challenges, the proven benefits of the Shahbazim model, particularly in enhancing resident well-being and staff satisfaction, provide a strong impetus for continued exploration, adaptation, and integration efforts within the broader long-term care ecosystem. Creative solutions, policy advocacy, and collaborative partnerships are essential to overcome these barriers and realize the transformative potential of this person-centered approach.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

7. Conclusion: The Transformative Potential of the Shahbazim Model

The Shahbazim stand as exemplary figures in the Green House model, embodying a truly holistic, person-centered, and deeply relational approach to elder care. Their role represents a deliberate and profound departure from the conventional, often criticized, institutional paradigms of long-term care. Through their comprehensive responsibilities – encompassing personalized clinical care, culinary artistry, meticulous household management, and crucially, the cultivation of profound human connections – Shahbazim are instrumental in transforming care settings into genuine homes where residents can experience dignity, purpose, and a truly meaningful life.

The rigorous and extensive training undergone by Shahbazim, which far exceeds traditional caregiver requirements, equips them with an elevated skill set that bridges the gap between basic direct care and clinical observation, while also fostering critical competencies in culinary arts, household management, and advanced communication. This investment in their professional development, coupled with an empowered, self-managed team structure, significantly contributes to their higher job satisfaction and lower turnover rates, creating a stable and nurturing care environment. The comparative analysis unequivocally demonstrates that the Shahbazim model leads to superior resident outcomes, including reduced hospitalizations, improved functional status, decreased reliance on psychotropic medications, and an overall enhancement in residents’ psychological and social well-being. This symbiotic relationship between empowered staff and thriving residents underscores the model’s inherent strength.

However, the widespread integration of the Shahbazim model into existing broader healthcare systems is not without significant challenges. These include navigating complex regulatory frameworks, securing substantial initial financial investments for infrastructure and advanced training, addressing workforce recruitment and readiness, and, perhaps most critically, overcoming deep-seated cultural and organizational resistance to change. Shifting from a task-oriented, hierarchical system to one that champions autonomy, collaboration, and comprehensive care requires visionary leadership, strategic planning, and a steadfast commitment to culture transformation.

Despite these formidable barriers, the demonstrable benefits of the Green House model and the pivotal role of the Shahbazim warrant continuous consideration and further exploration. The model serves as a compelling blueprint for the future of long-term care, advocating for a paradigm where direct care workers are recognized as skilled professionals, where elder care is delivered in truly homelike environments, and where the focus is steadfastly on fostering human connection and individual flourishing. Future research should continue to refine best practices for training and integration, explore innovative funding mechanisms, and rigorously evaluate long-term societal impacts. By embracing the principles embedded within the Shahbazim model, the healthcare industry has a profound opportunity to redefine aging, ensuring that later life is lived with dignity, joy, and purpose.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

References

• Afendulis, C. C., Caudry, D. J., O’Malley, A. J., Kemper, P., & Grabowski, D. C. (2016). Green House Adoption and Nursing Home Quality. Health Services Research, 51(Suppl 1), 454–474. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
• Bowers, B. J., Nolet, K., Jacobson, N., & the THRIVE Research Collaborative. (2016). Sustaining Culture Change: Experiences in the Green House Model. Health Services Research, 51(Suppl 1), 398–417. europepmc.org
• Cohen, L. W., Zimmerman, S., Reed, D., Brown, P., Bowers, B. J., Nolet, K., Hudak, S., & Horn, S. (2016). The Green House Model of Nursing Home Care in Design and Implementation. Health Services Research, 51(Suppl 1), 352–377. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
• Reinhard, S. C., Hado, E., Bowers, S., Ryan, S., & DeVries, M. (2022). Empowered Direct Care Worker: Lessons from the Green House Staffing Model. Center for Health Care Strategies. chcs.org
• Zimmerman, S., Shier, V., & Saliba, D. (2014). Transforming Nursing Home Culture: Evidence for Practice and Policy. The Gerontologist, 54(Suppl 1), S1–S5. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov