Implications of Classifying Data Centres as Critical National Infrastructure for the Healthcare Sector

Abstract

In September 2024, the UK government officially designated data centres as Critical National Infrastructure (CNI), an acknowledgement of their indispensable role in underpinning a vast array of essential services, most notably the healthcare sector. This comprehensive research report meticulously examines the far-reaching and multifaceted implications of this pivotal classification for hospitals, clinics, and the broader healthcare ecosystem. It delves deeply into the intricate layers of regulatory frameworks that now govern these facilities, the significantly heightened security standards mandated, and the enhanced compliance requirements, with a particular focus on the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and its interplay with the CNI status. Furthermore, the report explores the nature of potential government support and the imposition of specific mandates, scrutinising their direct impact on strategic investments in cybersecurity within healthcare institutions operating within or dependent upon the CNI ecosystem. By dissecting these critical dimensions, this report aims to furnish a profound and exhaustive understanding of the imperative for, and mechanisms towards, significantly enhanced data security and resilience within the healthcare domain.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

1. Introduction: The Digital Imperative and the CNI Classification

The landscape of modern healthcare has undergone a profound transformation, moving from predominantly paper-based systems to an intricately digitalised environment. This paradigm shift has fostered an unprecedented and continually escalating reliance on data centres, which serve as the foundational repositories for storing, processing, and transmitting highly sensitive patient information. From Electronic Health Records (EHRs) and diagnostic imaging to telehealth consultations, remote patient monitoring, and the burgeoning application of artificial intelligence in clinical decision support, every facet of contemporary healthcare delivery is now inextricably linked to the robust and uninterrupted functioning of data infrastructure. This pervasive reliance renders healthcare particularly vulnerable to disruptions originating from cyberattacks, system failures, or natural disasters.

Recognising the critical and increasingly existential role these facilities play in national stability and public well-being, the UK government made the landmark decision in September 2024 to classify data centres as Critical National Infrastructure (CNI). This strategic declaration is not merely a symbolic gesture but a substantive policy shift, fundamentally underscoring the imperative of safeguarding these digital fortresses to ensure the continuity, integrity, and security of essential services, with the healthcare sector standing as a paramount beneficiary and stakeholder. The classification signifies a national recognition that the failure or disruption of data centre operations could lead to severe societal and economic consequences, including widespread disruption to public services, significant economic damage, and, critically for healthcare, potential threats to life and public health.

This comprehensive report embarks on a detailed investigation into the multifaceted implications of this CNI classification. It will meticulously explore the evolving regulatory frameworks that now govern data centre operations, the significantly elevated security standards and compliance requirements that operators must adhere to, and the specific mandates and forms of support extended by the government. A central focus will be placed on how these changes influence strategic cybersecurity investments and operational postures within healthcare institutions, whether they operate their own data centres or, more commonly, rely on third-party CNI-designated providers. The overarching objective is to provide a holistic and in-depth analysis of the heightened necessity for robust data security and operational resilience in the healthcare sector, ensuring the uninterrupted delivery of vital patient care in an increasingly complex and interconnected digital world.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

2. Regulatory Frameworks Governing Data Centres as CNI

The designation of data centres as CNI introduces a formidable and comprehensive regulatory framework, meticulously designed to bolster the resilience, security, and operational integrity of these vital facilities. This framework mandates a structured approach to risk management, incident response, and continuous improvement in cybersecurity posture. Understanding its key components is crucial for any organisation operating within or relying upon the UK’s digital infrastructure.

2.1 Network and Information Systems (NIS) Regulations 2018

The Network and Information Systems (NIS) Regulations 2018 established the initial legal framework in the UK, derived from the EU’s NIS Directive, aimed at enhancing the cybersecurity of essential network and information systems. These regulations imposed significant obligations on Operators of Essential Services (OES) and Relevant Digital Service Providers (RDSPs) to enhance their cyber resilience. With data centres now classified as CNI, their inclusion, or indeed the reinforcement of their existing obligations as OES, necessitates a more stringent adherence to these regulations.

Under the NIS Regulations, data centre operators, now unequivocally recognised for their criticality, are obligated to:

• Implement Appropriate and Proportionate Security Measures: This involves adopting technical and organisational measures to manage risks to the security of network and information systems. These measures must be state-of-the-art and tailored to the specific risks faced, ensuring the security of data and the continuity of services. For data centres, this extends to physical security, operational technology (OT) security for critical infrastructure elements (e.g., power, cooling systems), and comprehensive IT security across their entire infrastructure.
• Prevent Incidents and Mitigate Their Impact: Operators must proactively identify and assess risks, deploying controls to prevent incidents, and establishing robust capabilities to mitigate the impact of any incidents that do occur. This includes comprehensive patching, vulnerability management, security architecture design, and the implementation of a strong security culture.
• Notify the Competent Authority of Incidents Affecting Service Delivery: A critical obligation is the timely reporting of incidents that have a significant impact on the continuity of the essential service. For data centres, this could involve outages, significant cyberattacks, or any event compromising data integrity or availability. The threshold for notification is typically defined by criteria such as the number of users affected, the duration of the incident, or its geographic spread. The National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) and the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) often serve as the primary competent authorities for such notifications, coordinating with other relevant sector-specific regulators.

The CNI designation significantly reinforces these obligations, necessitating data centre operators to adopt even more stringent security measures, invest in advanced threat detection and response capabilities, and maintain comprehensive, rigorous incident reporting protocols. The accountability for non-compliance is substantial, with potential for significant financial penalties, underscoring the seriousness of these requirements.

2.2 Cyber Security and Resilience Bill (and Broader Legislative Landscape)

The original article referenced a ‘proposed Cyber Security and Resilience Bill’. While specific legislative titles and progress can evolve, the spirit of this anticipated legislation reflects a broader governmental intent to continually strengthen the UK’s cyber defences. This overarching legislative drive aims to expand the scope beyond the initial NIS Regulations, ensuring a wider range of digital services and their complex supply chains are adequately protected from escalating cyber threats. For data centres, this means an increased focus on the security of their upstream and downstream dependencies.

Key themes often present in such legislative initiatives, and highly pertinent to CNI-designated data centres, include:

• Supply Chain Security: Recognising that a significant proportion of cyberattacks originate within the supply chain, new legislation often mandates that providers of essential infrastructure protect their supply chains. This requires rigorous due diligence on third-party vendors, contractual obligations for security, and ongoing monitoring of supply chain risks. For healthcare, which relies on a vast and intricate network of software providers, cloud services, and medical device manufacturers, this focus is paramount.
• Proactive Regulatory Powers: Future legislative developments typically empower regulators with enhanced capabilities to investigate, audit, and enforce cybersecurity standards. This may include powers to conduct mandatory security audits, request information, issue directives for security improvements, and impose penalties for non-compliance. Such powers are particularly vital in sectors like healthcare, which are frequently targeted by sophisticated cyber adversaries due to the high value and sensitive nature of patient data.
• Resilience Mandates: Beyond mere security, there is an increasing emphasis on operational resilience – the ability of organisations to anticipate, withstand, recover from, and adapt to disruptive incidents. For CNI data centres, this translates into requirements for robust business continuity planning, disaster recovery capabilities, redundant systems, and regular testing of these plans to ensure service availability even under extreme duress.

While the specific legislative instrument may vary, the UK’s National Cyber Strategy 2022 sets a clear direction: to bolster the nation’s cyber resilience across all critical sectors. This strategy often leverages frameworks such as the NCSC’s Cyber Assessment Framework (CAF), which provides a structured approach to assessing an organisation’s cyber resilience, offering a practical implementation guide for the principles mandated by regulations like NIS. The CAF outlines 14 principles covering organisational governance, risk management, and technical security, providing a benchmark against which CNI operators, including data centres, can measure and improve their security posture.

2.3 Sector-Specific Guidance and Standards for Healthcare

Beyond the overarching NIS Regulations and prospective national legislation, the healthcare sector itself is subject to specific data security and protection requirements. In the UK, NHS Digital, now part of NHS England, has historically provided guidance and frameworks like the Data Security and Protection Toolkit (DSPT). The DSPT is an online self-assessment tool that allows health and social care organisations to measure their performance against the National Data Guardian’s 10 data security standards.

With data centres classified as CNI, healthcare organisations relying on these facilities will find their own DSPT obligations implicitly elevated. They will need to ensure that their chosen data centre providers can unequivocally demonstrate compliance with the CNI standards, which inherently exceed general DSPT requirements in terms of resilience, threat intelligence, and government oversight. This creates a cascading effect: CNI status of data centres necessitates heightened due diligence and contractual assurances from healthcare providers regarding their data storage infrastructure.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

3. Enhanced Security Standards and Compliance Requirements

The CNI designation mandates a significant escalation in the implementation of advanced security measures, extending beyond conventional cybersecurity to encompass robust physical security and comprehensive operational resilience protocols. This holistic approach is designed to fortify data centres against a diverse spectrum of threats, ranging from sophisticated cyberattacks and malicious insider activity to widespread IT outages and environmental emergencies.

3.1 Advanced Security Measures

Data centre operators, particularly those serving the critical healthcare sector, are now compelled to adopt and maintain cutting-edge security technologies and methodologies. These measures form a multi-layered defence strategy:

3.1.1 Cybersecurity Technologies

• Advanced Encryption: Data must be encrypted both ‘in transit’ (during transmission across networks) and ‘at rest’ (when stored on servers or storage devices). This involves robust cryptographic algorithms (e.g., AES-256) and secure key management systems. For highly sensitive healthcare data, advanced concepts like homomorphic encryption, which allows computation on encrypted data without decrypting it, are areas of ongoing research and potential future deployment, significantly enhancing data privacy while maintaining utility.
• Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): MFA is now a baseline requirement, moving beyond simple password protection. This includes various forms such as biometric authentication (fingerprint, iris, facial recognition, vein mapping), hardware security tokens (e.g., FIDO keys), smart cards, and adaptive MFA that considers contextual factors like user location or device. For critical systems, privileged access management (PAM) solutions ensure that elevated access is granted only when strictly necessary and for limited durations, subject to robust auditing.
• Intrusion Detection and Prevention Systems (IDS/IPS): These systems are no longer merely signature-based but incorporate sophisticated Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) capabilities. AI/ML algorithms analyse network traffic and system logs for anomalous behaviour, identifying subtle indicators of compromise that traditional methods might miss. This enables real-time threat identification, automated response actions (IPS), and proactive mitigation of zero-day exploits.
• Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) and Security Orchestration, Automation, and Response (SOAR) Platforms: SIEM systems aggregate and analyse security logs from across the entire infrastructure, providing a centralised view of security events. SOAR platforms build upon SIEM by automating repetitive security tasks, orchestrating complex incident response workflows, and enabling faster and more consistent reactions to threats. These systems are crucial for maintaining continuous situational awareness and rapid incident containment.
• Zero Trust Architecture (ZTA): Moving away from the traditional perimeter-based security model, ZTA operates on the principle of ‘never trust, always verify’. Every user, device, and application attempting to access resources, whether inside or outside the network perimeter, must be authenticated and authorised. This micro-segmentation approach significantly limits lateral movement for attackers and reduces the blast radius of any breach.
• Threat Intelligence Integration: Data centres must integrate real-time threat intelligence feeds from government agencies (like the NCSC), industry peers, and commercial providers. This intelligence provides early warnings of emerging threats, indicators of compromise (IoCs), and attack methodologies, allowing operators to proactively strengthen their defences and fine-tune their detection systems.
• Data Loss Prevention (DLP): DLP solutions are critical for healthcare data centres to prevent sensitive patient information from being exfiltrated or misused. These systems monitor, detect, and block sensitive data from leaving the organisation’s control through various channels (email, cloud storage, removable media, network transfers).
• Cloud Security Posture Management (CSPM): For data centres leveraging cloud infrastructure (hybrid or multi-cloud environments), CSPM tools automate the identification and remediation of cloud configuration errors, policy violations, and compliance risks, ensuring that cloud environments adhere to CNI security standards.

3.1.2 Physical Security Enhancements

The CNI designation mandates a robust, multi-layered approach to physical security to prevent unauthorised access and ensure the continuous operation of critical infrastructure:

• Layered Perimeter Defence: This includes hardened perimeters with anti-climb fencing, hostile vehicle mitigation barriers, and strict access control points (e.g., mantraps, turnstiles) for both vehicular and pedestrian entry.
• Advanced Access Controls: Beyond basic card access, biometric access controls (fingerprint, iris, facial recognition, vein mapping) are implemented at various entry points within the facility, ensuring only authorised personnel can access sensitive areas. These systems are often integrated with identity management solutions for comprehensive audit trails.
• Video Surveillance and Analytics: High-resolution CCTV systems cover all critical internal and external areas, monitored 24/7. Advanced video analytics, often powered by AI, automatically detect anomalous behaviour, object detection (e.g., abandoned packages), facial recognition, and intrusion attempts, triggering immediate alerts to security personnel.
• Remote Monitoring Systems: Centralised security operations centres (SOCs), often geographically dispersed for redundancy, provide continuous oversight of physical security systems, environmental conditions, and IT infrastructure. This allows for rapid response to any anomaly, whether physical breach or system malfunction.
• Environmental Controls and Resilience: CNI data centres must incorporate advanced environmental monitoring (temperature, humidity, air quality), fire suppression systems (e.g., inert gas systems), and robust power redundancy (multiple utility feeds, uninterruptible power supplies (UPS), and generators with significant fuel reserves). Furthermore, they must consider climate risks, as highlighted by some experts, including potential failure due to extreme weather events like floods or prolonged heatwaves, necessitating advanced cooling and flood protection measures (newcivilengineer.com).
• Personnel Security: Comprehensive vetting processes, ongoing background checks, and robust training programmes for all staff, including contractors, are essential to mitigate insider threats. Clear policies on access privileges and least privilege principles are rigorously enforced.

3.2 Compliance with GDPR in the CNI Context

The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) imposes stringent data protection standards on any organisation processing personal data of individuals within the European Union (and by extension, the UK post-Brexit via the UK GDPR). For data centres classified as CNI, particularly those handling highly sensitive patient health information, compliance with GDPR is not merely a legal obligation but a paramount ethical and operational imperative.

GDPR principles, now rigorously applied in the CNI context, include:

• Lawfulness, Fairness, and Transparency: Data processing must be lawful, fair, and transparent to the data subject. For CNI data centres, this means clear policies on data handling, robust legal bases for processing healthcare data (e.g., public interest in health, explicit consent), and transparent communication with healthcare clients regarding sub-processing arrangements.
• Purpose Limitation: Personal data must be collected for specified, explicit, and legitimate purposes and not further processed in a manner that is incompatible with those purposes. Data centres must ensure their operational practices align strictly with the purposes for which healthcare data is entrusted to them.
• Data Minimisation: Only personal data that is adequate, relevant, and limited to what is necessary in relation to the purposes for which it is processed should be handled. CNI data centres, while hosting vast quantities of data, must support their healthcare clients in implementing data minimisation principles at the application layer.
• Accuracy: Personal data must be accurate and, where necessary, kept up to date. Every reasonable step must be taken to ensure that personal data that are inaccurate, having regard to the purposes for which they are processed, are erased or rectified without delay. Data centres must provide robust infrastructure to support the integrity and accuracy of stored data.
• Storage Limitation: Personal data should be kept in a form which permits identification of data subjects for no longer than is necessary for the purposes for which the personal data are processed. Data centres must facilitate the secure deletion or anonymisation of data according to their clients’ retention policies.
• Integrity and Confidentiality (Security): This principle is profoundly reinforced by the CNI designation. It requires personal data to be processed in a manner that ensures appropriate security, including protection against unauthorised or unlawful processing and against accidental loss, destruction, or damage, using appropriate technical or organisational measures. For CNI data centres, this means implementing all the advanced security measures detailed in section 3.1.
• Accountability: The data controller (e.g., the hospital) is responsible for, and must be able to demonstrate compliance with, the GDPR principles. Data centres, acting as processors, must provide the necessary contractual assurances, audit reports, and technical capabilities to enable their healthcare clients to meet this accountability requirement.

Specific GDPR compliance requirements within the CNI context entail:

• Data Protection by Design and by Default: This fundamental principle requires that data protection considerations are embedded into the design and operation of all data processing systems and business practices from the outset. For CNI data centres, this means integrating robust security measures (e.g., encryption, pseudonymisation, stringent access controls, secure configurations) into every layer of their infrastructure and service delivery, ensuring privacy-enhancing technologies are the default settings (redteamworldwide.com).
• Data Protection Impact Assessments (DPIAs): When processing operations are likely to result in a ‘high risk’ to the rights and freedoms of individuals – an almost certainty for healthcare data – a DPIA is mandatory. Data centres must be prepared to contribute necessary information to their healthcare clients’ DPIAs, detailing their security measures, data handling practices, and risk mitigation strategies. This often involves demonstrating compliance with recognised security standards and certifications.
• Robust Incident Response Plans: GDPR mandates prompt and effective responses to data breaches. CNI data centres must have meticulously detailed incident response plans that align with GDPR’s notification requirements. This includes the ability to detect a breach swiftly, assess its scope and impact, contain it, remediate the vulnerabilities, and notify the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) within 72 hours of becoming aware of the breach, where feasible. For healthcare data, this timeline is even more critical due to the potential for significant harm to individuals.
• International Data Transfers: If CNI data centres are part of a global network or transfer data outside the UK/EEA, they must ensure these transfers comply with GDPR rules, which generally require adequate safeguards like Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs), Binding Corporate Rules (BCRs), or adequacy decisions. This is crucial for healthcare organisations utilising global cloud providers.

The CNI status profoundly elevates the need for data centres to uphold these GDPR standards with unparalleled rigour. The heightened risks associated with their critical role in supporting essential services, combined with the sensitive nature of healthcare data, mean that any failure in GDPR compliance could lead to catastrophic consequences, including severe penalties, reputational damage, and, most importantly, a profound erosion of patient trust.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

4. Government Support and Mandates

The designation of data centres as CNI is not solely about imposing additional burdens; it also entitles these critical facilities to enhanced government support and creates mechanisms for coordinated national security efforts. This support is particularly advantageous for healthcare institutions, which rely heavily on these facilities for their operational continuity and data integrity. The collaborative framework established aims to bolster national resilience against cyber and other threats.

4.1 Dedicated CNI Data Infrastructure Team

Recognising the strategic importance of data centres, the UK government has established a dedicated team of senior government officials specifically tasked with monitoring potential threats to these critical facilities. This team is designed to provide a centralised point of contact and coordination for intelligence sharing and response efforts. Its composition is typically multi-departmental, involving experts from the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (DSIT), the National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC), intelligence agencies (e.g., GCHQ), and potentially other departments relevant to critical infrastructure, like the Department of Health and Social Care.

The primary functions of this dedicated CNI Data Infrastructure Team include:

• Proactive Threat Monitoring and Intelligence Sharing: The team continuously monitors the cyber threat landscape, identifies emerging vulnerabilities, and assesses potential risks to data centres. It then disseminates timely and actionable threat intelligence to designated CNI operators. This includes providing details on specific threat actors, their tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs), and indicators of compromise (IoCs). For healthcare data centres, this real-time intelligence is invaluable in proactively hardening defences against evolving cyber campaigns targeting the health sector.
• Coordinated Incident Response: In the event of a significant cyber incident or IT blackout affecting a CNI data centre, this team coordinates a rapid, multi-agency response. This involves liaising with security agencies, law enforcement (e.g., National Crime Agency – NCA), and emergency services to ensure swift containment, recovery, and forensic analysis. This level of coordinated support is paramount for healthcare data centres, where service disruptions can have severe and immediate consequences for patient care, potentially impacting emergency services, surgical scheduling, or drug prescriptions.
• Policy Development and Guidance: The team also plays a crucial role in shaping government policy related to data centre security and resilience, contributing to legislative reviews and developing best practice guidance. They work to ensure that regulatory frameworks remain current and effective in addressing the dynamic threat environment.
• Horizon Scanning: Beyond immediate threats, the team engages in horizon scanning to anticipate future risks, such as those posed by quantum computing advancements, new adversarial techniques, or emerging geopolitical tensions. This proactive approach helps in preparing the industry for long-term challenges.

This dedicated government team provides a critical layer of national oversight and support, ensuring that even the most sophisticated threats can be addressed with coordinated national capabilities. The ability to tap into this expertise and resource pool is a significant benefit for healthcare organisations that rely on CNI data centres.

4.2 Prioritized Access to Security Agencies

One of the most tangible benefits of the CNI classification for data centres is the prioritised access to and direct engagement with the UK’s leading security agencies. This privileged access facilitates immediate and comprehensive assistance during cyber incidents, bolstering the overall security posture of data centres and, by extension, the critical services they support.

This prioritised access translates into:

• Direct Lines of Communication: CNI operators typically have dedicated, secure channels of communication with key security agencies, particularly the NCSC. This allows for rapid exchange of information, urgent requests for assistance, and direct consultation on emerging threats or vulnerabilities.
• Expedited Incident Response Support: In the event of a significant cyberattack, CNI data centres receive priority support from NCSC’s incident management teams. This includes expert advice on containment strategies, eradication, recovery planning, and post-incident analysis. For healthcare data centres, this swift intervention can mean the difference between a minor disruption and a catastrophic systemic failure.
• Forensic Analysis Capabilities: The NCSC and other agencies can offer advanced forensic analysis services to help CNI data centres understand the nature and scope of an attack, identify the threat actors, and gather intelligence for future defence. This level of expertise is often beyond the capabilities of individual organisations.
• Bespoke Intelligence Briefings: CNI operators may receive tailored intelligence briefings on specific threats relevant to their sector or infrastructure. This proactive intelligence allows data centres to implement defensive measures before they become targets.
• Joint Exercises and Simulations: CNI data centres are encouraged, and often expected, to participate in national cyber security exercises and simulations. These drills, often led by the NCSC, test incident response plans, communication protocols, and overall resilience in a controlled environment, ensuring that capabilities are robust when real incidents occur.

This deep collaboration significantly enhances the collective resilience of the healthcare sector. By ensuring that sensitive patient information and critical healthcare operations are backed by the full weight of the UK’s cyber defence capabilities, the CNI designation provides a crucial layer of protection against the increasingly sophisticated and persistent cyber threats targeting the healthcare sector.

4.3 Potential for Funding and Incentives

While the direct provision of large-scale government funding might be selective, the CNI designation opens avenues for various forms of governmental and regulatory support that can ease the financial burden of compliance and incentivise best practices. These include:

• Targeted Grants and Research Funding: The government may offer specific grants for research and development into advanced security technologies or resilience solutions applicable to CNI, encouraging innovation within the data centre industry.
• Tax Incentives: Although not explicitly announced, governments often consider tax incentives or accelerated depreciation for investments in critical infrastructure security, recognising the public good derived from private sector investment in this area.
• Procurement Policies: Government procurement frameworks for IT services, particularly for the NHS, will likely favour or mandate the use of CNI-compliant data centre providers. This creates a market incentive for data centres to achieve and maintain the CNI standard.
• Access to Expertise and Training: Beyond direct incident support, the NCSC and other agencies provide extensive guidance, frameworks, and training opportunities for cybersecurity professionals. While not direct funding, this investment in human capital is invaluable for data centre operators and healthcare organisations alike.

These support mechanisms underscore the government’s commitment to creating a secure and resilient digital backbone for the nation, where the financial and operational burden of enhanced security is, to some extent, shared or facilitated through strategic partnerships and incentives.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

5. Impact on Strategic Investments in Cybersecurity

The classification of data centres as CNI fundamentally reshapes the strategic investment priorities within healthcare institutions, whether they own and operate their own data infrastructure or, more commonly, rely on third-party providers. The heightened regulatory scrutiny, the increased threat landscape, and the explicit recognition of criticality compel healthcare organisations to re-evaluate their cybersecurity posture and allocate resources accordingly.

5.1 Increased Investment in Cybersecurity Infrastructure and Capabilities

Healthcare organisations are now compelled to significantly increase their investment in a broad spectrum of cybersecurity measures to meet the elevated standards required for CNI compliance and to ensure the security of data flowing through or residing within these critical facilities. This represents a strategic shift from treating cybersecurity as a compliance checkbox to viewing it as a core, indispensable component of operational resilience and patient safety.

Key areas of increased investment include:

• Upgrading Existing Security Infrastructure: This involves migrating from legacy security tools to state-of-the-art solutions such as next-generation firewalls (NGFWs) with advanced threat prevention capabilities, sophisticated Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) and Extended Detection and Response (XDR) platforms, and robust Identity and Access Management (IAM) systems. For healthcare, where a mix of on-premises, cloud, and edge devices are common, this requires a comprehensive, integrated security architecture.
• Implementing Advanced Threat Detection and Response Systems: Investment in SIEM and SOAR platforms becomes critical for aggregating security alerts, correlating events, and automating responses. Furthermore, the adoption of Security Operations Centres (SOCs), either in-house or via Managed Security Service Providers (MSSPs), capable of 24/7 monitoring, threat hunting, and rapid incident response, is now an essential expenditure. These SOCs are crucial for detecting sophisticated, stealthy attacks that bypass traditional defences.
• Investing in Data Governance and Compliance Tools: To manage the complexities of GDPR and CNI compliance, healthcare organisations will invest in data classification tools, data discovery solutions, and privacy management platforms. These tools help identify, categorise, and protect sensitive patient data across all its lifecycle stages.
• Regular Security Audits and Vulnerability Assessments: Beyond one-off assessments, there will be a continuous investment in penetration testing, vulnerability scanning, and red teaming exercises. These simulate real-world attacks to identify and address potential weaknesses proactively, ensuring that the security posture matures in line with evolving threats. For healthcare, this extends to medical devices and IoT infrastructure connected to patient data networks.
• Resilience Planning and Disaster Recovery Infrastructure: Investment in redundant systems, geographically dispersed data backup facilities, and comprehensive Business Continuity Planning (BCP) and Disaster Recovery (DR) capabilities are paramount. This ensures that even in the face of a major incident, critical healthcare services can be restored rapidly, minimising disruption to patient care.
• Cyber Insurance: While not a security control, robust cyber insurance policies become a necessity for CNI-aligned healthcare organisations. Insurers are increasingly scrutinising the cybersecurity posture of their clients, and CNI compliance will likely become a prerequisite for obtaining adequate coverage, potentially at more favourable terms.
• Research and Development: Healthcare institutions and their technology partners may increasingly invest in R&D into emerging security paradigms, such as post-quantum cryptography readiness, homomorphic encryption, or blockchain for data integrity, anticipating future threats and technological shifts.

The financial implications of these increased investments are substantial. Healthcare institutions will need to re-evaluate their budgeting, potentially reallocating funds from other IT areas or seeking additional funding. The cost-benefit analysis of security investments will shift, with the ‘cost of inaction’ (e.g., potential patient harm, regulatory fines, reputational damage from a breach) far outweighing the cost of proactive security measures.

5.2 Enhanced Collaboration and Information Sharing

The CNI status fosters a significantly greater degree of collaboration and structured information sharing between healthcare institutions, CNI data centre operators, and government agencies. This collaborative ecosystem is a cornerstone of national cyber resilience, acknowledging that no single entity can effectively combat sophisticated cyber threats in isolation.

Key aspects of enhanced collaboration include:

• Public-Private Partnerships: Formal and informal partnerships between government bodies (e.g., NCSC, NHS England) and private sector data centre operators and healthcare providers are strengthened. These partnerships facilitate direct dialogue, joint threat analysis, and coordinated response strategies. This is vital for aligning security efforts across the entire digital health ecosystem.
• Information Sharing and Analysis Centres (ISACs): The CNI designation encourages active participation in sector-specific information sharing platforms. While the UK does not have a formal ‘Health ISAC’ like in the US, entities such as NHS Digital (now part of NHS England) effectively serve this function, sharing threat intelligence, vulnerabilities, and best practices. CNI data centres serving healthcare will be more deeply integrated into these information flows.
• Joint Exercises and Simulations: Regular joint exercises, often simulating complex cyberattacks on CNI, test the readiness and interoperability of public and private sector entities. These exercises identify gaps in incident response plans, improve communication protocols, and build trusted relationships essential during actual crises. Healthcare IT teams and their CNI data centre partners will participate in more such drills.
• Academic and Industry Partnerships: Collaboration extends to academic institutions for cybersecurity research and talent development, and to industry groups for developing common standards and best practices. This fosters an ecosystem of continuous learning and adaptation.
• Supply Chain Risk Management Collaboration: Healthcare organisations will work more closely with their CNI data centre providers to ensure robust supply chain security. This involves shared risk assessments, audits of sub-contractors, and alignment on security controls throughout the entire data processing chain.

The benefits of this enhanced information sharing are profound: collective defence capabilities are strengthened, early warnings of emerging threats enable proactive mitigation, lessons learned from incidents are rapidly disseminated, and common best practices are established, elevating the security posture of the entire sector. While challenges such as trust, legal frameworks for sharing sensitive information, and commercial sensitivities exist, the CNI designation provides a powerful impetus to overcome these barriers, recognising the overarching national interest in secure and resilient essential services.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

6. Broader Implications for Healthcare

The UK government’s decision to classify data centres as Critical National Infrastructure has ramifications that extend far beyond technical security measures and regulatory compliance. For the healthcare sector, this designation fundamentally alters the operational, strategic, and even ethical landscape, reinforcing the imperative of robust digital foundations for patient care.

6.1 Enhancing Patient Trust and Confidence

In an era where data breaches are increasingly common and often headline news, public trust in healthcare providers’ ability to safeguard sensitive personal and medical information is paramount. The CNI designation, by mandating and demonstrating a higher level of security and resilience for the underlying data infrastructure, can significantly bolster patient trust. When patients are confident that their health records are meticulously protected from cyber threats, unauthorised access, or accidental loss, they are more likely to engage fully with digital health initiatives, share necessary information, and feel secure in the healthcare system. This increased trust is vital for the successful adoption of telemedicine, digital prescriptions, and personal health apps, all of which rely heavily on secure data centres.

Conversely, a major data breach impacting CNI-classified data centres could severely erode this trust, leading to patient reluctance to use digital services, potential legal challenges, and significant reputational damage to healthcare providers and the NHS as a whole. Thus, the CNI status acts as a powerful public assurance mechanism, signalling a national commitment to data security at the highest level.

6.2 Ensuring Operational Continuity and Patient Safety

For healthcare, data centres are not just storage facilities; they are the lifeblood of operational continuity. Electronic health records, diagnostic imaging systems, laboratory results, prescription systems, patient scheduling, and critical administrative functions all depend on the uninterrupted availability and integrity of data. A significant outage or cyberattack on a data centre could lead to:

• Disruption of Patient Care: Inability to access patient histories, allergies, or current medications could lead to medical errors, delayed diagnoses, or unsafe treatments.
• Impact on Emergency Services: Critical systems supporting ambulance dispatch, emergency room admissions, and real-time patient status updates could be compromised, potentially delaying life-saving interventions.
• Loss of Operational Capacity: Hospitals might be forced to revert to manual, paper-based systems, significantly slowing down operations, increasing wait times, and reducing overall patient throughput. This could lead to cancelled appointments, postponed surgeries, and reduced capacity for new admissions.
• Supply Chain Disruptions: Digital systems manage inventory for medications, medical devices, and supplies. An attack could disrupt these systems, leading to shortages of critical items.

The CNI designation directly addresses these risks by mandating resilience and rapid recovery capabilities. This ensures that even in the face of significant cyberattacks or technical failures, the critical data required for patient safety and continuity of care remains accessible and reliable. The focus shifts from merely protecting data to ensuring the availability of essential health services.

6.3 Facilitating Innovation and Digital Transformation

Paradoxically, while imposing stricter security requirements, the CNI designation can also act as an accelerator for innovation and further digital transformation within healthcare. A robust and secure data infrastructure provides the essential foundation upon which advanced digital health solutions can be built with confidence. Innovators and developers are more likely to create and deploy cutting-edge technologies – such as AI-driven diagnostics, advanced telemedicine platforms, remote monitoring solutions, and precision medicine initiatives – if they are assured that the underlying data processing and storage systems meet the highest national security standards.

Without this assurance, concerns about data privacy, security, and system resilience would inhibit the adoption of new technologies, hindering the potential for efficiency gains, improved patient outcomes, and cost savings that digitalisation promises. The CNI status effectively de-risks the digital landscape for healthcare innovation.

6.4 Enhancing Supply Chain Resilience in Healthcare IT

The healthcare sector’s reliance on a complex supply chain of IT vendors, software providers, cloud services, and managed service providers means that the security of any single link can affect the entire chain. The CNI designation for data centres has a cascading effect, compelling healthcare organisations to demand higher security assurances from all their third-party digital service providers. This means:

• Rigor in Vendor Selection: Healthcare providers will place an even greater emphasis on the cybersecurity posture of prospective data centre providers and other IT vendors, requiring evidence of CNI compliance, ISO 27001 certification, Cyber Essentials Plus, and robust security audit reports.
• Stronger Contractual Obligations: Contracts with data centre operators and other IT service providers will include more stringent clauses regarding cybersecurity standards, incident response times, audit rights, and liability in case of breaches.
• Joint Risk Management: Collaborative risk assessments and continuous monitoring of third-party vendors will become standard practice, ensuring that risks originating from the supply chain are systematically identified and mitigated.

This heightened focus on supply chain security strengthens the overall resilience of healthcare IT systems, protecting against vulnerabilities introduced by external partners.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

7. Challenges and Future Outlook

The classification of data centres as Critical National Infrastructure represents a significant leap forward in bolstering the UK’s digital resilience. However, its implementation and ongoing effectiveness in the context of healthcare will not be without challenges, and the future outlook remains dynamic.

7.1 Key Challenges

• Funding Constraints within the NHS: Despite the clear benefits, the financial implications of upgrading to CNI-level security can be substantial. The NHS operates under perpetual budgetary pressures, and securing sufficient funding for essential cybersecurity investments, alongside other pressing healthcare demands, will be a persistent challenge. While government support exists, it may not fully offset the required capital expenditure and operational costs.
• Legacy IT Systems in Healthcare: Many healthcare institutions, particularly within the NHS, still rely on a patchwork of older, sometimes outdated, IT systems. Integrating these legacy systems securely with CNI-compliant data centres and ensuring their resilience presents a significant technical and financial hurdle. Modernising these systems while maintaining continuity of care is a complex undertaking.
• Critical Cybersecurity Skills Gap: The demand for skilled cybersecurity professionals far outstrips supply globally. Attracting, training, and retaining top talent to manage and maintain CNI-level security in both data centres and healthcare organisations will remain a critical challenge. The public sector, including the NHS, often struggles to compete with private sector salaries.
• Managing Complexity of Hybrid IT Environments: Healthcare data increasingly resides across a complex mix of on-premises servers, private cloud, public cloud, and edge devices (e.g., IoT medical devices). Ensuring consistent CNI-level security and compliance across such heterogeneous and distributed environments adds significant complexity to security management and incident response.
• Evolving Threat Landscape: Cyber adversaries are continually evolving their tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs). Ransomware remains a pervasive and increasingly sophisticated threat, nation-state actors target critical infrastructure for espionage and disruption, and the advent of AI-driven attacks promises new levels of sophistication. Staying ahead of these threats requires constant vigilance, adaptation, and investment, making CNI compliance a moving target rather than a fixed state.
• Climate Risks and Physical Resilience: As highlighted by experts, data centres, like other infrastructure, are vulnerable to climate change impacts such as extreme heat (affecting cooling systems), flooding, and severe weather events. Ensuring physical resilience against these growing environmental threats, beyond just cyber threats, adds another layer of complexity and cost to CNI designation, as it necessitates investment in robust environmental controls and site selection strategies (newcivilengineer.com).
• Interoperability and Data Sharing Challenges: While data centres being CNI improve the security of data at rest and in transit, true benefits for patient care require seamless and secure data sharing across disparate systems and organisations within healthcare. Overcoming technical and organisational barriers to interoperability while maintaining CNI-level security and GDPR compliance remains an ongoing challenge.

7.2 Future Outlook

Despite these challenges, the trajectory set by the CNI designation points towards a more secure and resilient future for UK healthcare:

• Continuous Adaptation of Regulations: The regulatory framework, including NIS Regulations, will likely continue to evolve (e.g., in response to the EU’s NIS2 Directive, even if the UK diverges, the core principles of enhanced resilience will likely remain). This will necessitate ongoing adjustments by data centres and healthcare providers to maintain compliance.
• Integration of AI for Defence and Attack: AI will play an increasingly dual role – both as a powerful tool for advanced threat detection, automated response, and predictive security analytics, and as a weapon for cyber adversaries to launch more sophisticated and evasive attacks. CNI security strategies will need to leverage AI defensively while preparing for AI-driven threats.
• Quantum Computing’s Role: The emergence of quantum computing poses a long-term threat to current cryptographic standards. Future CNI requirements will likely include mandates for ‘quantum-safe’ cryptography, necessitating significant research and infrastructure upgrades.
• Deepening International Cooperation: Cyber threats are global, requiring international collaboration. The UK’s CNI designation may foster deeper cooperation with international partners on intelligence sharing, joint exercises, and harmonisation of cybersecurity standards, benefiting the healthcare sector by extending the reach of collective defence.
• Focus on Human Factors: Recognising that human error and insider threats remain significant vulnerabilities, future efforts will likely place increased emphasis on comprehensive security awareness training, strong security culture, and robust insider threat programmes within both data centres and healthcare organisations.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

8. Conclusion

The UK government’s strategic decision to classify data centres as Critical National Infrastructure in September 2024 represents a profound and necessary evolution in national security and digital resilience. This landmark designation unequivocally acknowledges the indispensable role these facilities play in underpinning essential services, particularly the highly sensitive and critically important healthcare sector. By establishing a comprehensive and rigorous regulatory framework, mandating advanced security standards, fostering deep collaboration, and providing targeted government support, this initiative aims to mitigate the escalating risks associated with sophisticated cyber threats, pervasive IT disruptions, and emerging environmental challenges.

For healthcare institutions, this classification necessitates a proactive and fundamental shift in their approach to cybersecurity and operational resilience. It compels them to significantly increase strategic investments in advanced security infrastructure, cultivate a highly skilled cybersecurity workforce, and rigorously ensure compliance with an intricate web of regulatory requirements, most notably the GDPR and the enhanced NIS Regulations. Furthermore, it demands a deeper and more integrated collaboration with CNI-designated data centre providers and government security agencies, fostering a collective defence mechanism against a dynamic and increasingly hostile threat landscape.

While the journey towards achieving and maintaining CNI-level security in the healthcare domain will undoubtedly present significant challenges, including financial constraints, legacy IT systems, and the persistent cybersecurity skills gap, the overarching imperative remains clear. This proactive and holistic approach is not merely a matter of regulatory adherence; it is an essential undertaking to safeguard sensitive patient information, ensure the uninterrupted continuity of critical healthcare services, and ultimately, protect patient safety and public trust in an increasingly digital and interconnected world. The CNI designation serves as a powerful testament to the UK’s commitment to building a resilient digital future for its healthcare system, ensuring that the foundational elements of modern medicine are as secure and robust as the services they enable.

Many thanks to our sponsor Esdebe who helped us prepare this research report.

References

• UK data centres to be designated critical infrastructure. Financial Times. (ft.com)
• UK to class data centres as ‘critical national infrastructure’. Reuters. (reuters.com)
• Cybersecurity Implications of Data Centres as Critical National Infrastructure. Infosecurity Europe. (infosecurityeurope.com)
• UK Government classifies data centres as Critical National Infrastructure. GOV.UK. (gov.uk)
• Essential Cybersecurity Compliance Requirements: GDPR, HIPAA, PCI DSS & More. RedTeam Worldwide. (redteamworldwide.com)
• The UK’s Decision to Classify Data Centres as Critical National Infrastructure: What It Means for Operators and the Nation. Datalec UK. (datalecltd.com)
• Data Centres Given Critical National Infrastructure Status In Britain. Cybersecurity Intelligence. (cybersecurityintelligence.com)
• Value of data centres to UK economy highlighted by government action. Pinsent Masons. (pinsentmasons.com)
• Warning about ‘critical national infrastructure’ data centres’ failure due to climate risks. New Civil Engineer. (newcivilengineer.com)